Salem Witch Trials: The Dark History of America's Deadliest Witch Hunt
October 27, 2026
171
01:28:13

Salem Witch Trials: The Dark History of America's Deadliest Witch Hunt

In 1692, an enslaved woman named Tituba told a Salem courtroom that the Devil had come to her and bid her serve him. Her confession lit the fuse that would become known as the infamous Salem witch trials, the deadliest witch hunt in American history.

The Salem witch trials saw a village of 500 people accuse more than a third of its own population of witchcraft, hang nineteen of them, and press one man to death for refusing to plead. The strangest part is not that it happened, but how easily a God-fearing community talked itself into it.


In 1692, an enslaved woman named Tituba told a Salem courtroom that the Devil had come to her and bid her serve him. Her confession lit the fuse that would become known as the infamous Salem witch trials, the deadliest witch hunt in American history.

In February 1692, two young girls in the household of Salem Village's new minister began screaming, convulsing and complaining that someone was pricking them with pins. A doctor could find nothing wrong, so the village reached for the only explanation its worldview allowed: the Devil. Within weeks, an enslaved woman named Tituba had confessed in front of the whole village, claimed there were more names written in the Devil's book, and set off the deadliest witch hunt in American history.

What followed was pure mass hysteria. Accusations spread from marginalised women to respected church members, then to a four-year-old girl, then to a former minister living in another colony, until 200 people from a village of 500 sat in prison awaiting trial. The courts convicted on spectral evidence, testimony that the accused's ghost had attacked someone in the night, which meant no alibi on earth could save you. 

To understand how it got there, we go back through centuries of European witch hunting, the Reformation chaos that drove the Puritans across the Atlantic, and the culture of moral surveillance they built in the New World, where every neighbour was watching every other neighbour for signs of hidden sin. This is the story of what really caused the Salem witch trials, and why the comfortable explanations, like hallucinogenic rye fungus, miss the far more unsettling truth.

What Happened in the Salem Witch Trials?

The Salem witch trials began in Salem Village, the rural Massachusetts settlement now known as Danvers, in early 1692. Betty Parris and Abigail Williams, the nine-year-old daughter and eleven-year-old niece of minister Samuel Parris, began suffering strange fits: screaming, contorting under furniture, and complaining of being pricked with pins. When Dr William Griggs could find no physical cause, the diagnosis became an "Evil Hand". Two more girls, Ann Putnam Jr and Elizabeth Hubbard, soon showed the same symptoms.

After a neighbour's folk-magic "witch cake" ritual failed to reveal a tormentor, pressure mounted for the girls to name someone. They pointed at three of the most marginalised people in the village: Tituba, an enslaved woman in the Parris household, the beggar Sarah Good, and the bedridden Sarah Osborne. At her examination, Tituba stunned the village by confessing. She described serving the Devil, then claimed there were more names in the Devil's book that she could not read. Her confession appeared to spare her from the gallows, and it became the survival playbook: throughout the trials, not a single person who confessed was executed.

The accusations spread with terrifying speed. Respected church members Martha Corey and Rebecca Nurse were accused, seemingly for questioning the girls or through old grudges. Four-year-old Dorothy Good was arrested and interrogated in custom-made shackles. By May, 62 people had been accused; by September, 200 were in prison from a village of 500. The convictions rested on spectral evidence, testimony that the accused's spirit had attacked someone, which no alibi could counter. Bridget Bishop, who it turns out was originally from Norwich, became the first to hang on 10 June 1692. Giles Corey refused to enter a plea at all, and was pressed to death under heavy stones, answering every demand to plead with the words "more weight", a strategy that kept his estate from being seized.

Everything collapsed in October 1692, when accusations reached prominent figures including Lady Mary Phips, the governor's wife. The governor dissolved the court, the replacement court refused spectral evidence, and almost everyone tried afterwards was exonerated. Nineteen people had been hanged, Giles Corey pressed to death, and several more had died in prison. The reckoning took far longer: a day of fasting in 1697, a partial reversal of convictions in 1711, further recognitions in 1957 and 2001, and finally, in 2022, the exoneration of Elizabeth Johnson Jr, secured by a class of schoolchildren, 330 years after the trials.

Why This Story Matters

For centuries, people have looked for a tidy external cause for Salem, and the most famous theory blames ergot, a hallucinogenic fungus in contaminated rye. It is a comforting explanation precisely because it lets everyone off the hook. The far more uncomfortable truth is that Salem needed no poison. It grew from things entirely human: a theology that made the Devil the explanation for every misfortune, a doctrine of predestination that turned neighbours into moral surveillance, a legal system willing to accept ghosts as witnesses, and a tangle of feuds, land disputes and resentments that accusation conveniently settled.

Salem also shows how hysteria ends, which is almost as revealing as how it begins. The trials did not stop because the evidence was re-examined or because the accusers recanted. They stopped the moment the accusations reached someone powerful. That pattern, of a panic that only becomes intolerable when it threatens the influential, has repeated throughout history, and it is why Salem remains the reference point every time a community turns on itself. The story matters because the machinery that produced it, fear, certainty, conformity and the search for someone to blame, was never uniquely Puritan. It was, and is, ours.

Topics Include

  • what caused the Salem witch trials

  • Tituba's confession and the Devil's book

  • spectral evidence explained

  • the executions of Bridget Bishop and Giles Corey

  • how the trials ended and the 2022 exoneration

  • the Puritan beliefs behind the hysteria

Resources and Further Reading

[00:00:00] Kyle Risi: You've probably heard the explanation that Salem was poisoned, contaminated, rye, maybe a fungus that had plunged an entire village into a state of hallucinating their witches existed.

[00:00:12] Adam Cox: That's the version I know. Yeah,

[00:00:15] Kyle Risi: it's neat. It's plausible, and it lets everyone off the hook. But the real story is actually centuries in the making, a hundred thousand people accused across Europe, a society where God controlled the weather, the harvest, and of course your soul

[00:00:28] Adam Cox: and your neighbours were watching your every move.

[00:00:32] Kyle Risi: And then one book handed them a playbook for turning a grudge into accusation. So when the hanging started, nobody stopped. Not even when it was a grandmother, not even when Adam, it was a child.

[00:00:45] Adam Cox: So if it wasn't the bread, then what was it?

[00:00:48] Kyle Risi: That's the uncomfortable part, Adam. It was human nature.

Welcome to the Compendium and Assembly of Fascinating Things, a weekly variety podcast that gives you just enough information to stand your ground. At any social gathering.

[00:01:25] Adam Cox: We explore strange, true stories from the worlds of true crime, dark history, scandals, mysteries, and remarkable people.

[00:01:33] Kyle Risi: I'm Kyle Reese, your ringmaster for this week's episode.

[00:01:36] Adam Cox: And I'm Adam Cox, the Chief Boo in the audience reducer. That's the technical term.

[00:01:42] Kyle Risi: That's how bad we are, that we need a boo reduction officer.

[00:01:46] Adam Cox: That's right. You know, just like, you know, in Eurovision, sometimes Israel will get a few boos. Who

[00:01:51] Kyle Risi: political can't get political.

[00:01:53] Adam Cox: I'm just referencing something so people understand what I'm talking about.

[00:01:56] Kyle Risi: Mm-hmm.

[00:01:56] Adam Cox: Um,

[00:01:57] Kyle Risi: like Iron American listeners will definitely know, right?

[00:01:58] Adam Cox: Yeah. So yeah, that's because, you know, to stop the rest of the audience here in the booze, I'll be there basically making a distraction.

[00:02:09] Kyle Risi: And get your tits out.

[00:02:10] Adam Cox: Look at me. Look over there.

[00:02:14] Kyle Risi: They do that with Trump a lot, don't they? Don't they like do boo suppression for Trump's speeches?

[00:02:18] Adam Cox: Probably.

[00:02:19] Kyle Risi: They like football games.

[00:02:20] Adam Cox: I can imagine it.

[00:02:21] Kyle Risi: Oh my god. Can you imagine being in that position like, sir, you are that unpopular? We're gonna have to fish out the boo suppressor. And he's like, oh, they must love me.

[00:02:31] Adam Cox: We're just gonna green screen you in this time.

[00:02:33] Kyle Risi: Yeah. So you're not even there. Guys. If you are new to the show and you wanna support us, then the absolute best way that you can support the show and enjoy some exclusive perks is to join us over at Patreon, because signing up is free.

And you will get access to next week's episode a whole seven days before anyone else.

[00:02:48] Adam Cox: And for as little as $5 a month, you can become a fellow freak of the show, which will unlock our entire back catalogue.

[00:02:55] Kyle Risi: No exclusive episodes that they wanna listen to. Nothing. None of that.

[00:02:59] Adam Cox: Well, there might be exclusive episodes.

Go, go. Have a look and you'll find out.

[00:03:03] Kyle Risi: Yeah, maybe that's not to guarantee yet. This is like the beginning of season four. We haven't even recorded any yet.

[00:03:09] Adam Cox: We will.

[00:03:10] Kyle Risi: But guys, let's be honest, the real reason to sign up as a certified free core, big top tier member is that you'll get exclusive access to our compendium key chain.

So we can always be there dangling Adam, right there.

[00:03:22] Adam Cox: Near your crotch.

[00:03:23] Kyle Risi: Near your crotch.

[00:03:24] Adam Cox: And lastly, guys, please follow us on your favourite podcast app and leave us a review. 'cause your support helps others find us and keeps these amazing stories coming.

[00:03:34] Kyle Risi: Right, Adam, that is enough of the housekeeping, because today on the compendium, we are diving into an assembly of moral panic, borrow, blame, and the price for refusing.

It's a lie,

[00:03:46] Adam Cox: refusing to lie.

[00:03:48] Kyle Risi: Mm-hmm.

[00:03:48] Adam Cox: What does that mean,

[00:03:50] Kyle Risi: Adam? Let's paint a little bit of a picture, right?

[00:03:52] Adam Cox: Mm-hmm.

[00:03:52] Kyle Risi: On the 1st of March, 1692,

[00:03:55] Adam Cox: we're going way back.

[00:03:56] Kyle Risi: Way back. An enslaved woman known as Tituba, appeared shackled before ministers in the local village hall to answer for her alleged crime. Now, TBA wasn't the only person being questioned that day.

Townsfolk Sarah Goode and Sarah Osborne were also being questioned over the same accusation, but they denied all charges. However, when TBA stepped into the dock, she didn't deny the charges against her local minister, John Hawthorne asked TBA plainly, did you see the devil? And TBA responded, yes, the devil came and bid me, serve him.

John then asked. What did he ask you to do? To which Sper responded to hurt the children? Now Adam, these words, these were the words John Hawthorne had been waiting for. Sarah Goode and Sarah Osborne had failed to confess. And so when TPA said these words, it finally brought an end to the search for an explanation for all the strange happenings going on throughout the village and ushered in the systematic hunt for witches.

[00:05:02] Adam Cox: So someone actually volunteered that they were a witch? Yes.

[00:05:06] Kyle Risi: Adam, today on the compendium, I'm gonna tell you about the 1692 Salem Witch Trials.

[00:05:14] Adam Cox: Oh, so this is how Sabrina the Witch started?

[00:05:17] Kyle Risi: Yes, correct.

[00:05:19] Adam Cox: This is like the prequel.

[00:05:21] Kyle Risi: Yes. Way back. What do you know about the Salem Witch?

[00:05:25] Adam Cox: Uh, it happened in Salem.

[00:05:27] Kyle Risi: Mm-hmm.

[00:05:27] Adam Cox: Uh, Sabrina's Witch is called Salem.

[00:05:30] Kyle Risi: Yes.

[00:05:30] Adam Cox: And that's pretty much it.

[00:05:33] Kyle Risi: It's such, that was such a good show, wasn't it? After researching this, so many reels started coming up from Sabrina, the Teenage Witch. And do you know who I forgot that I love the most

[00:05:42] Adam Cox: Harvey.

[00:05:43] Kyle Risi: I'm not a pig. It's not always about sex.

Adam. No, Hilda.

[00:05:49] Adam Cox: Oh yeah. Well, the arts were great.

[00:05:50] Kyle Risi: Yeah. The answer were awesome. Like I really loved Hilda. But when I was looking through all these reels, what really surprised me is that in my mind, I remember her being way bigger or like a bit more Tu than the other aunts. But actually in real life she wasn't.

She wasn't at all. So like that, I don't know. I think that's kind of a symptom of the 1990s when we have this kind of notion that, oh, you had to be a certain size. Mm-hmm. But she completely fine. She looked great.

[00:06:18] Adam Cox: Yeah. She was, I can't remember if I've seen her in anything else but Zelda, you've seen her in a few things.

[00:06:22] Kyle Risi: Yes.

[00:06:23] Adam Cox: She was in Lost and I'm sure a few other shows.

[00:06:26] Kyle Risi: Mm-hmm. Anyway, such a great show. But Adam, today's story is Wild. For our listeners who don't know, the Salem Witch Trials were a series of witchcraft accusations that took place in Colonial Massachusetts between 1692 and 1693. And it was basically a series of events that plunged an entire community into literal mass hysteria.

And Adam, it is a wild story. The hysteria that erupted from Tituba's Confession reached a point where more than a third of the village's total population were imprisoned.

[00:06:59] Adam Cox: That's a lot of people.

[00:07:01] Kyle Risi: So many, all your neighbours. Can you imagine this entire estate being just chucked into jail?

[00:07:05] Adam Cox: I think it's just someone that wants to like do a sweep up of, you know, the local community.

They just don't like a lot of people.

[00:07:12] Kyle Risi: Adam, you wait.

[00:07:14] Adam Cox: Oh

[00:07:14] Kyle Risi: yeah. But by the time this hysteria was over 19 of those people had been put to death with five more dying as a result of the awful conditions in the village prison, including a man who was pressed to death because he literally refused to enter in a plea of innocent or guilty

[00:07:29] Adam Cox: pressed to death.

[00:07:30] Kyle Risi: Yeah, it's, it was not great.

[00:07:32] Adam Cox: That sounds as bad as it sounds.

[00:07:35] Kyle Risi: It is, yeah. Pretty bad. And I mean, like while the deaths were horrific enough, what makes the story of Salem so fascinating to historians especially, is how the hysteria seemed to infect an entire community. Like for centuries, people have tried to explain how this could even happen.

How does an entire village become so consumed by fear and suspicion that they were willing to sentence each other to death? Because when something as horrifying as this happens, there's like a natural inclination to seek out a definitive cause followed by like immeasurable effect, right? Mm-hmm. Like we, we want that moment where we can say, there it is.

That is where everything completely went off the rails. But people never really got a satisfactory answer as to why. And it's because there's always something deeply uncomfortable about exploring an area where subconsciously we know the truth. 'cause the last thing we want to believe is that when a society loses its mind, it's because of our own making.

And so for a long time, Salem was explained within this framework that absolved us of all responsibility, something that deflected the blame and offered a very neat, plausible explanation. You've probably heard some of these, right? Do you know what I'm gonna say? What comes to mind when you think about what caused Salem?

[00:08:50] Adam Cox: I don't know. Was it just people thinking that someone was possessed by the devil?

[00:08:54] Kyle Risi: I mean, that is what they were saying, right?

[00:08:56] Adam Cox: Yeah.

[00:08:56] Kyle Risi: But when historians look back, it was thought that they were just simply victims of consuming rye that was contaminated with ergot. And you'll probably remember the term ergot from our MK Ultra episode, because that is a fungus that is capable of causing convulsions and hallucinations.

[00:09:12] Adam Cox: Oh, this is another, I didn't realise this was at the, or potentially at the root cause of why people behaved how they were,

[00:09:19] Kyle Risi: Adam. This explanation was both neat and plausible. It didn't require us to look inward, but that's exactly what Salem was. It was a mirror that we were holding up to human nature because the explanation about the infected rye and ergot has been completely discounted.

[00:09:35] Adam Cox: Oh,

[00:09:35] Kyle Risi: it's not even possible for where they were in the world. Instead, it was something that our history and Psyche suggested was actually something that was really inevitable. And so it was, it. It's just shit. Humans.

[00:09:51] Adam Cox: Oh us again.

[00:09:52] Kyle Risi: Us, us again. Oh, we are the problem. Hi, it's me. I'm the problem. Is that how the song goes?

I don't know any. It's I, us with songs.

[00:10:00] Adam Cox: Close enough.

[00:10:01] Kyle Risi: Thanks. And so, Adam, today we are gonna explore why today we'll follow the crisis and how it began and how it ended up coming to Salem and consuming them. We'll also look at the strange behaviour of the children at the centre of these accusations, and how Tituba's Confession transformed a local disturbance into evidence of a Satanic conspiracy, how the accusations spread, and also why confessing to witchcraft was typically safer than denying it.

[00:10:33] Adam Cox: So I'm guessing if you confess, and maybe you're just put in prison, but if you deny it, you'll burn at the stake.

[00:10:39] Kyle Risi: Yes. And there's a couple, uh, myths that we're gonna, uh, debunk today as well, because witches were not typically burnt at the stake because it was considered a crime under English law that lumped it in with heresy.

And so the punishment for that was hanging. Now, that's not to say that some witches across Europe weren't burnt at the stake, but typically the Puritans, they were British settles. Mm. And so, um, the crime for that was hanging. So that kind of debunks a bit of the myth. It takes away a bit of the drama from all of this.

Do you know what I mean? Not to say that we should be celebrating the deaths of these kind of poor women, but still it, like, when you think about the witch trials, you think about burning witches at the stake.

[00:11:16] Adam Cox: Yeah. It sounds, yeah. Horrendous in terms of their treatment.

[00:11:19] Kyle Risi: Mm-hmm.

[00:11:19] Adam Cox: So this is kind of like the first Satanic panic.

[00:11:22] Kyle Risi: That's the thing though, right? Because. Salem isn't the start of all the witchcraft. They didn't invent it right for literally 500 years. Witchcraft has been a major thing across Europe, but yes, it is a moral panic. Mm-hmm. If you will, because it kind of caused the hysteria across the entire community. And so it's a really interesting episode that I'm excited to dive into.

But we're also going to explore how the authorities eventually lost control of the system that they physically created. 'cause remember, these were settlers from the old world, right. Coming to the new world to to, to do everything from scratch. And very quickly they lost control of it. And that also had a lot to do with the events that happened in Salem.

But I'm also, Adam really excited because today's story of Salem has a surprising connection to our hometown of Norwich. Oh really? Mm. Yeah. In a couple ways. But um, in a lot of the kind of pre-contact that I kind of wrote into this, Ben subsequently took out, because it made this episode like 15,000 words.

Yeah. There's just one of 'em. But there were two

[00:12:25] Adam Cox: Two, okay.

[00:12:26] Kyle Risi: Yeah.

[00:12:26] Adam Cox: So when, when are you gonna get to that bit? That sounds interesting.

[00:12:28] Kyle Risi: Yeah. We'll get into that as we go through. But Adam, as I said, the people of Salem, they didn't invent the idea of witchcraft. They arrived in North America carrying centuries of European beliefs about magic demons and the devil.

Like during the roughly 200 years leading up to the Salem witch trials, more than a hundred thousand people across Europe had been prosecuted of witchcraft with somewhere between like 40,000 and 60,000 of them being executed. Some by obviously being burnt at the stake, but especially in kind of western Europe, a lot of it was just being hanged.

[00:13:00] Adam Cox: Am I right in saying that? Some were like put on a chair and then drowned in a river?

[00:13:04] Kyle Risi: We'll get into that because that was part of, um, the tests on how to test if someone was a witch. Now, of course, it won't surprise you to know that the vast majority of those people that were prosecuted were of course women.

However, what is interesting is that that was just overall, but in places like Iceland and Estonia mostly accused, like 92% of them were actually men.

[00:13:27] Adam Cox: So like being accused of being wizards,

[00:13:29] Kyle Risi: wizards or witches, I think, I dunno, when their classification between Warlock and Witches came along, but yeah, they were just lumped in with that.

And most of the people prosecute were men.

[00:13:36] Adam Cox: What's the difference between a warlock and a wizard?

[00:13:38] Kyle Risi: I don't know.

[00:13:39] Adam Cox: I mean, a wizard has a nice long beard and a pointy hat.

[00:13:43] Kyle Risi: Why kinda warlock of that?

[00:13:44] Adam Cox: I don't, I feel like he should be living under a bridge,

[00:13:47] Kyle Risi: a troll,

[00:13:50] Adam Cox: but shit is just a guy with a white beard.

That's how you know,

[00:13:54] Kyle Risi: I think he's also like performing magic and stuff. You know, he's in a role which might suggest, hmm, something's up. But also across Europe. This was an extraordinarily brutal time. It was shaped by religious persecution, torture, executions, and like a deeply misogynistic belief about women being more vulnerable to the influence of the devil.

And so that played a massive factor as to why so many women were blamed. And over the generations religious authorities, judges, writers, together, they all constructed an increasingly elaborate mythology around what witches were supposed to be. Because remember, for most of early European history, healers and shamans and midwives were essential members of communities across Europe.

Like if your cow got sick or your crops failed, these were the people that you went to. These were just superstitions. They didn't really mean anything. No one cared about them. But as the Roman Catholic Church started getting more and more influence across Europe, these people were no longer simply healers and shamans.

They were essentially servants of Satan who had entered into a contract with them.

[00:14:57] Adam Cox: So people that were like helping the community with, I dunno, medicines or like herbal remedies and things like that

[00:15:03] Kyle Risi: Yeah.

[00:15:03] Adam Cox: Are then being accused of going, well, actually this is a bit too

[00:15:07] Kyle Risi: now, in order to kind of make that fit, what they did is they had to try to draw a parallel between.

The heretics and an old superstition of these healers and these shamans. And what they did is they started to say, well, if a shaman was able to go ahead and heal your cow or to restore your crops because like the winter was failing, then he couldn't have done that on his own. He had to have had assistance, and that had to have come from a demon or the devil.

I

[00:15:35] Adam Cox: see.

[00:15:35] Kyle Risi: And so straight away, that is something that went against the Christian doctrine, and suddenly they now had a parallel between heretics and witches. They were now essentially lumped in with the same thing because the church, remember, they gained all this power in Europe and they wanted to make sure that they could hold onto that power.

And the way that you could do that is to make sure that you can control what people thought and believed. And so Adam, by the time the Salem Puritan sailed to North America, the idea of a witch being this ungodly figure had already become part of a vast invisible conspiracy. They believed that they knew what witches were capable of.

They knew what signs to look for, and they believed that failing to uncover them could place an entire community into danger.

[00:16:17] Adam Cox: When did witches with green skin like come into fashion?

[00:16:21] Kyle Risi: I don't know if that was kind of more of a modern thing. Do you know what I mean? With alphabet from the The Wizard.

[00:16:26] Adam Cox: Wizard, yeah. But I thought, oh, so she was the first green witch.

[00:16:30] Kyle Risi: I don't, honestly, I don't know. I don't know. But yeah, that's my point is that the history of witchcraft across kind of Europe is so vast, stretches 500 years. It's just, there's so much to it, and there's all these things that end up converging that creates the mythology of what people think witchcraft is in light of kind of religious doctrine.

[00:16:49] Adam Cox: Yeah. I'd love to know when, just the things that we think of a witch, like the pointy hat, the crooked nose lying on a broomstick came from.

[00:16:56] Kyle Risi: Well, I think that's why that justifies having an entire episode just dedicated on European witch hunting. Do you know what I mean? We couldn't cover it all, unfortunately.

But we don't need to explore the complete history of European witchcraft to understand what happened in Salem. I think we can kind of, I can. I can make it work. Basically, we do need to understand how one particular group of English Protestants carried those beliefs across Atlantic and built a society in which sin was literally everybody's business.

And so we are going to start today's episode at a very crucial point in the story that will help explain the religious conflict in which all of this was allowed to happen. And so we are travelling back to England during the English Reformation.

[00:17:37] Adam Cox: Ah, good old English reformation. What a great time that was.

[00:17:41] Kyle Risi: I know, right? I know. So from our Guy Forgs episode that we did earlier this year, what do you remember about this period and what it was like for Protestants and Catholics specifically?

[00:17:51] Adam Cox: Well, considering this is the second time we're, we're recording this part.

[00:17:54] Kyle Risi: Oh, because we forgot to press record,

[00:17:56] Adam Cox: we then I can tell you.

[00:17:59] Kyle Risi: Go on then.

[00:18:00] Adam Cox: Um, so during that point we had, uh, king Henry viii. Obviously, he, um, you know, changed the religion and people were flip flopping back and forth between Catholicism and protest. Mm-hmm.

[00:18:13] Kyle Risi: Well done. Good words, hard words, Adam, hard words.

[00:18:16] Adam Cox: Um, and that's all because of King Henry viii. Right.

[00:18:19] Kyle Risi: He wanted to decide who he.

Put his toad in too

[00:18:24] Adam Cox: graphs. Okay.

[00:18:26] Kyle Risi: So basically after King Henry VIII died in 1547, there was almost like a century of his heirs, including Elizabeth, I, Mary, queen of Scots and James, the first all flip-flopping between protest and, uh, Catholicism. See, I can't even say it.

[00:18:39] Adam Cox: Catholicism. I can do

[00:18:39] Kyle Risi: Catholicism.

[00:18:40] Adam Cox: Pro, pro does Theism. I

[00:18:42] Kyle Risi: dunno.

[00:18:42] Adam Cox: Yeah, it's confusing.

[00:18:44] Kyle Risi: The point is, as, as a result, this ended up being a very scary time for ordinary people. It didn't matter whether or not you were Catholic or Protestant, if the Monarch died and their successor believed something different, you would wake up one morning and suddenly your whole family were being systematically persecuted.

From that moment on, things got even more complicated. When King James, I first came to the throne, and even though King James was a Protestant, his wife was Catholic. And so even though it seemed like things were gonna be a little bit more relaxed, people were still on edge. Right? They spent so many years flip-flopping between persecuting Catholics and persecuting Protestants that they didn't know where they stood.

Like, could King James change his mind tomorrow? People just didn't know, like being Protestant or Catholic and what the current Monarch was at the time, define who you were and what that said about your status in society. If that was no longer important, what did that mean for your identity? But also think about all the countless people that have been murdered between these battles between the two.

Right. Suddenly that was all for nothing.

[00:19:45] Adam Cox: Yeah. You, you've given your life. Um, and then yeah, the next week or a sudden it doesn't. Yeah, it doesn't make a difference.

[00:19:51] Kyle Risi: Exactly.

Do

[00:19:51] Adam Cox: you know what they needed back then?

[00:19:53] Kyle Risi: What

[00:19:53] Adam Cox: they needed? Like a reversible tablecloth.

[00:19:56] Kyle Risi: Okay,

[00:19:56] Adam Cox: so one day it's out, it's Catholicism,

[00:19:59] Kyle Risi: uhhuh,

[00:19:59] Adam Cox: and then the new king comes in and like you can just flip it over and there's Protestant tablecloth.

[00:20:02] Kyle Risi: Well, that's exactly what it was.

[00:20:03] Adam Cox: Yeah. But that's what I mean. Like you can just blend in. You can just like, uh, you know,

[00:20:06] Kyle Risi: yeah.

[00:20:07] Adam Cox: Take down the Protestant flag and put up the capitalism.

[00:20:10] Kyle Risi: But it's, it's so much more complicated than that because you can't just change your beliefs, turn them off and switch over to the other side.

Right. Because that is essentially who, how you define yourself.

[00:20:20] Adam Cox: I know, but this is how I blend in.

[00:20:21] Kyle Risi: Okay. Okay.

[00:20:21] Adam Cox: Didn't matter. I would believe what I want to believe in private.

[00:20:24] Kyle Risi: So you'd be a heretic in in undercover.

[00:20:27] Adam Cox: Yeah.

[00:20:27] Kyle Risi: Okay. Yeah. That's it. Like, that's the problem is that you just needed to be able to lie effectively.

Just lie, who cares?

[00:20:34] Adam Cox: And people just didn't wanna do that, I guess.

[00:20:35] Kyle Risi: No, people didn't wanna do that. And so Adam, it's added this uncertainty that emerged a group of Protestants known as the Puritans who started voicing complaints that they didn't feel like England was Protestant enough. Like they had a king.

Yeah, he was Protestant, but he had a Catholic wife. And people were like, mm, don't like that.

[00:20:50] Adam Cox: Yeah.

[00:20:51] Kyle Risi: And so for years they tried pushing England towards stricter Protestant values through various machinations within governments.

[00:20:58] Adam Cox: Right.

[00:20:59] Kyle Risi: However, this ended up backfiring after Charles the first came to the throne and the archbishop began cracking down on Puritan clergy.

Suddenly the puritan's dream of living in a country more closely aligned with Protestant values seemed further away than it ever had been. Right? But Adam, there was hope on the horizon. And when I say on the horizon, I mean literally.

[00:21:19] Adam Cox: France.

[00:21:20] Kyle Risi: Yeah. No, that's like Europe.

[00:21:24] Adam Cox: Oh, oh America.

[00:21:25] Kyle Risi: People know. People know about Europe.

[00:21:27] Adam Cox: Oh, that's right. Yeah. The new land.

[00:21:29] Kyle Risi: Yes, exactly. Because Cross Atlantic people had discovered what they called the New World. Right. A vast consonant that was free from the control of British Crown. And so for the very first time, a oppressed religious groups began wondering whether or not this could be a clean slate on which to build a brand new society entirely built on their own terms.

[00:21:46] Adam Cox: Yeah. It's not like no one lives there or anything. Yeah.

[00:21:49] Kyle Risi: Hey, we're not allowed to say that.

[00:21:51] Adam Cox: Well, and this is what I mean, just how stupid to think like, oh, we'll take over.

[00:21:54] Kyle Risi: Yeah. It's because they were indigenous people and they thought that they were more superior, basically.

[00:21:58] Adam Cox: Yeah.

[00:21:59] Kyle Risi: And so what you find is that from the 1630s entire Puritan families begin kind of leaving England for North America, where they believe that they could build a pure Bible-based society that they felt that England had failed to become.

Now, when we talk about early North American settlers, what often comes to mind are the pilgrims, right?

[00:22:16] Adam Cox: Mm-hmm.

[00:22:16] Kyle Risi: Heard of those terms before the pilgrims.

[00:22:18] Adam Cox: Yes.

[00:22:19] Kyle Risi: I mean, you've probably heard the pilgrims, but not very much the Puritans, right?

[00:22:22] Adam Cox: No, not really. What's the difference then?

[00:22:24] Kyle Risi: So I mean the, the pilgrims and the Puritans, they were both fleeing England.

Their motivations, however, were pointed in two very different directions. The pilgrims were essentially English separatists. It's the thing that Americans celebrate every year on Thanksgiving, right? It, it feeds into that fundamental value that Americans hold very dear, and that is the separation of church and state and pilgrims were those English separatists, right.

Who'd given up on not just the Church of England altogether, but also on kind of the British crown when they first leave England. They start, they were, and they were the first to leave England starting around about the 1620s. And their whole shtick was, we just wanna be left alone to worship in our own way.

No one should be interfering with that, which is the fundamental kind of foundation for a lot of American kind of values. Do you know what I mean?

[00:23:12] Adam Cox: Yeah.

[00:23:13] Kyle Risi: And so when they first arrived in North America, they established their Plymouth colony. So when you hear these stories about coming over on the Mayflower and all that stuff, they are the first settlers to come across, and they're very important in American history.

[00:23:25] Adam Cox: I wonder what that must have been like. They'd like look at the land and go like,

[00:23:29] Kyle Risi: it's a shit.

[00:23:30] Adam Cox: Or like dibs. Dibs on that tree.

[00:23:32] Kyle Risi: Yeah, yeah, yeah. This is where we get some of those really cool stories like Roanoke and places like that with these early colonies and like Jamestown and all sorts of crazy stuff.

We should do more episodes on those now. It isn't it until a decade later throughout the 1630s that the Puritans get the same idea and they also start leaving. While they weren't the first to settle North America, they were undoubtedly a much larger wave of people leaving England. And so when they arrive, they end up establishing the Massachusetts Bay Colony.

[00:23:59] Adam Cox: The spirit of Massachusetts is the Spirit of America,

[00:24:02] Kyle Risi: spirit of America, red, white, and Blue. That that song. Yeah. I love that song. The important distinction with the Puritans is that they wanted to build a model of England as it was basically, but on their own terms. And so in their new settlements, the Puritans were finally free to reform their faith on their own terms.

But in escaping what they saw as a religious persecution in England, they actually ended up creating a society that was in very many ways, just as intolerant as the one that they left behind.

[00:24:31] Adam Cox: So like, we're gonna take the best or the worst of this culture

[00:24:35] Kyle Risi: Uhhuh,

[00:24:35] Adam Cox: and we're gonna like ramp it up a little more.

[00:24:37] Kyle Risi: You say the best, we're gonna take the worst of this culture.

[00:24:39] Adam Cox: What they,

[00:24:39] Kyle Risi: and we're gonna wrap it up.

[00:24:40] Adam Cox: Yeah. They, what they considered the best.

[00:24:42] Kyle Risi: And I mean, honestly, this is one of the reasons why you don't really hear too much about the Puritans when it comes to like the Thanksgiving story. And it's because, um, they're not a great model to kind of like base an entire kind of like origin story.

[00:24:57] Adam Cox: So you don't want a holiday jumper with them on

[00:24:59] Kyle Risi: No, they were, they were much darker than the pilgrims,

[00:25:02] Adam Cox: right?

[00:25:02] Kyle Risi: Yeah. They weren't really campaigning for everyone to worship however they wanted. They wanted to build a society around their own interpretation of Christianity, which everyone has to follow. And so to make that work, church and governments were closely intertwined and everyone who challenged Puritan beliefs could either be fine, they could be banished or punished with the full force of law.

Because the two things are the same, right? Unlike what Americans believe, where separation between church and states, the Puritans were like, nah, church and state, same thing.

[00:25:31] Adam Cox: I see.

[00:25:31] Kyle Risi: Essentially they escaped the country, they're trying to control their religion only to establish a colony where they controlled everyone else's.

And so within this framework, God himself is placed at the very sense of everything and controls every aspect of their lives. He was both their purpose and their reason, he controlled things like the weather. It's all God's doing. If the village was struck down by disease or disaster or your crops failed, it was either punishment for sin or a test of their faith.

[00:26:01] Adam Cox: He's a bit of a micromanager, isn't he? This God,

[00:26:03] Kyle Risi: he's so micromanager. You just want someone to hands off, you know?

[00:26:06] Adam Cox: Yeah. Like can't they not just sort out their own harvest?

[00:26:09] Kyle Risi: No, that's one thing they can't do.

[00:26:11] Adam Cox: Oh, okay.

[00:26:11] Kyle Risi: Because it's dependent on the weather, right? Oh,

[00:26:12] Adam Cox: that's right. Yeah.

[00:26:14] Kyle Risi: And so it sounds horrible, like why would you worship a God who would do all of this to you?

But to them, Adam, to the Puritans, this dynamic gave them a real strong sense of significance. Like if God was taking the time to test them here in this foreign barren land, then they must be doing something important, right? Yeah. Like, yeah, exactly.

[00:26:33] Adam Cox: He's got a slot open on a Tuesday soon and he can just, you know, see what they're up to.

[00:26:37] Kyle Risi: Yeah. My very knee deep Puritan kids, they just need a little bit of attention.

[00:26:40] Adam Cox: Just some settling in.

[00:26:41] Kyle Risi: Yeah. And so God is looking down, going, Hmm, yeah. On that Tuesday. So you're doing really well down there. How about a curve ball? Bang,

[00:26:51] Adam Cox: what's the curve ball?

[00:26:52] Kyle Risi: Pubic hair lice outbreak. Really? Gotcha. No.

[00:26:56] Adam Cox: Oh, so what?

So what actually is true?

[00:26:59] Kyle Risi: Not that.

[00:27:00] Adam Cox: Okay.

[00:27:01] Kyle Risi: I mean, I'm sure there is pubic lice in the, in Puritan colonies at the time, but not in this episode.

[00:27:06] Adam Cox: Okay.

[00:27:06] Kyle Risi: Another important thing to understand about Puritans is that they believed in something called predestination. Do you know what that is?

[00:27:11] Adam Cox: No.

[00:27:12] Kyle Risi: It's basically this belief that before you were even born, God had already decided whether or not you were going to heaven or how what?

But he didn't tell you.

[00:27:20] Adam Cox: Well then what's the point?

[00:27:21] Kyle Risi: Right? No. So it didn't matter how well you lived your life, you could never be certain whether or not you're going to heaven. But they did believe that signs of your salvation were literally everywhere. And so in a society where good standing with God gave you status, Puritans become obsessed with looking for those clues, not only within themselves, but also within their neighbours.

[00:27:42] Adam Cox: What kind of clues? How can you tell?

[00:27:44] Kyle Risi: So things like how often do you go to church? How do you behave in public? Whether or not something suspicious had maybe happened in your family.

[00:27:53] Adam Cox: Do you put the bins out on time?

[00:27:54] Kyle Risi: Did you put the bins out on time? Exactly. Yeah.

[00:27:57] Adam Cox: Okay.

[00:27:57] Kyle Risi: And so as you can imagine, this creates this culture of gossip and moral surveillance where everybody is constantly watching everyone else just for signs of like hidden sin.

And it's the same today, really, when you think about it, like the thing that comes to mind is think about how we look at other people's moral behaviour during the pandemic, for example.

[00:28:16] Adam Cox: Right?

[00:28:16] Kyle Risi: Right. That was a scary time. There was that thing that we would do in England where we wanted to kind of celebrate nurses, Uhhuh, celebrate everyone in the NHS.

And then every Thursday at six o'clock, everyone across the entire country had to step onto their doorway and we just had to clap.

[00:28:32] Adam Cox: Yeah, no, not give them more money.

[00:28:34] Kyle Risi: No, we

[00:28:34] Adam Cox: just had to clap.

[00:28:35] Kyle Risi: Just give 'em a clap. And like people bang pots and stuff. But then like you would arrive in your doorstep and you were checking out to see who, who wasn't around.

You'd be like,

[00:28:42] Adam Cox: oh yeah. Who was lay out and you're like, you did two claps today.

[00:28:45] Kyle Risi: Yeah.

[00:28:46] Adam Cox: Wow.

[00:28:46] Kyle Risi: Or someone didn't show up. He's like, oh, Karen, next door classically hates nurses.

[00:28:50] Adam Cox: Yeah, I know.

[00:28:52] Kyle Risi: It's the same thing.

[00:28:53] Adam Cox: It was. It was this peer pressure, like I don't think we had a nurse that lived near us that could judge us.

[00:28:59] Kyle Risi: Do you think like nurses are coming out going. You didn't clap hard enough on reporting you.

[00:29:03] Adam Cox: I reckon they probably did.

[00:29:05] Kyle Risi: Probably. And so, Adam, as you can expect, this is the exact atmosphere where you would expect accusations of witchcraft to thrive in, right?

[00:29:11] Adam Cox: Mm-hmm.

[00:29:12] Kyle Risi: And so the Puritans had the perfect cultural environment for Salem to happen.

But what they needed though, what was missing was a playbook. And when I say a playbook, I mean a literal book. Okay? This book came in 1688 when four children of the Goodwin family in Boston started exhibiting some very odd and strange behaviour. And I'm talking like strange fits. Some of them were kind of plagued with temporary blindness and also some odd behaviour where they started just randomly barking like dogs.

[00:29:42] Adam Cox: That just sounds like any mother with four kids.

[00:29:44] Kyle Risi: Yeah. Like the, the kids are acting up, right?

[00:29:46] Adam Cox: Yeah,

[00:29:47] Kyle Risi: 100%. But in pur in society, the only possible explanation was that the children had been possessed by the devil himself.

[00:29:54] Adam Cox: Right? Okay.

[00:29:55] Kyle Risi: Which as a disruptive little kid, was almost like a get outta jail free card that completely absolves you of any responsibility for what you were doing.

[00:30:03] Adam Cox: Oh, that's okay. It's just the devil.

[00:30:05] Kyle Risi: Yeah, it's the

[00:30:05] Adam Cox: devil in Johnny.

[00:30:06] Kyle Risi: Ah, that little Skelly W. It's fine. And so, in effect, this gives them licence to continue, right? They weren't misbehaving Adam. They were literally victims,

[00:30:15] Adam Cox: right?

[00:30:15] Kyle Risi: And so when the children were asked who might be possessing them, they obviously wanted to continue being scaly wags.

And so they pointed the finger at the enemy of the family who was an elderly Irish Catholic widow named Ang Glover. And I say enemy because the Goodwins and the Glovers were already involved in dispute over some missing laundry. And so the Goodwins decide to bring in the local minister. He's a guy called Cotton Mather, and Cotton examines the kids.

And Adam, sure enough, he was like, yep, they're possessed. And so long story short, Anne Glover is subsequently tried and executed for witchcraft.

[00:30:51] Adam Cox: Oh. And just because they had it like beef with a neighbour.

[00:30:53] Kyle Risi: Yeah, it's awful. But Adam get this. Once Anne Glover is executed, the children had technically lost their excuse for behaving like cunts.

And so they are at a crossroads. They're like, guys, the witch is dead. Should we start behaving ourselves? And they were like, nah. If anything, the behaviour just got worse. And so you would think that the town's folk would reflect on this and maybe like reason that maybe just maybe we murdered the wrong person.

[00:31:25] Adam Cox: So they're not gonna behave now?

[00:31:27] Kyle Risi: No, no. They got worse. Unfortunately, cotton Mather has no interest in admitting that he might have got it wrong. 'cause by this point, the story had elevated his authority as an expert on witchcraft, like to a whole new level. And so a year later in 1689, cotton publishes a book called The Memorable Provenances relating to witchcraft and Possessions.

And in it's basically, he describes the children's symptoms, their strange behaviour, and all the supposed evidence that Glover had been a witch. And Adam, the book is hugely popular across colonies. And basically what Cotton Mather had done was hand everyone a convenient playbook for how to turn a dispute with a neighbour into an accusation for witchcraft.

[00:32:10] Adam Cox: What is his credentials? And like spotting devil children.

[00:32:14] Kyle Risi: I think he's like a minister.

[00:32:15] Adam Cox: Okay.

[00:32:16] Kyle Risi: So I, I'd say pretty high.

[00:32:17] Adam Cox: I know, but he's clearly not

[00:32:19] Kyle Risi: fired. No, no. And he's not, he's not thinking rationally. Right. Like the behaviour continued. So surely that must mean something. But no status, elevation more important to

[00:32:29] Adam Cox: Yeah.

He's not gonna admit his own mistake. And plus he probably still believes it.

[00:32:32] Kyle Risi: Oh yeah. No, 100% he does. Even throughout this whole, whole whole episode, he does. And so three years later in the small village of Salem, they now had everything that they needed to plunge their entire village into complete chaos.

But before I tell you what happened, it is important to understand the place where all of this began. Because at the time, there were actually two Salem. There was Salem Town and then Salem Village. Now Salem Village today is called Daver. And it's pretty much where all the Salem Wichita took place. Now, Salem Village is actually controlled by Salem Town, which was much larger, wealthier, and more powerful than the two.

And it sits directly on the coast, which connects it to trade. It gives them a lot of influence in the area. And so that's the reason why they're more powerful. Now, Salem Village of the other hand, is much smaller. It's essentially a rural area of farmlands surrounded by forests, which is ran about six miles away from Salem.

So back in the Puritan days, if you ever wanted to go into town, it's a six mile trek there and a six mile trek back.

[00:33:33] Adam Cox: Oh wow. So it's like, yeah, a couple of hours probably walking that.

[00:33:36] Kyle Risi: Yeah. And the population of Salem Village at this time is run by 500 people. But Adam, life in the village itself is really brutal.

Like it's hard across all of the colonies. But in this farmland that's barren and relatively new, it's really tough. A, the winters are super harsh, the work is relentless. Almost everything is done by hand. And Adam, their entire existence depends on successful harvest. Right. And successfully rearing livestock.

To add to this, the entire region is in the midst of yet another frontier war with the English fighting French forces and their indigenous allies and refugees would often arrive in town or in the village with stories of raids and killings. And so, as you can imagine, this only adds to the atmosphere of fear and violence that eventually, that violence might arrive into Salem Town.

[00:34:24] Adam Cox: Mm-hmm.

[00:34:25] Kyle Risi: So there's a few, we're building a recipe here, right? Because we're looking at all the different things that would influence how the hysteria could potentially happen. Before we start the story.

[00:34:34] Adam Cox: I see

[00:34:35] Kyle Risi: the next thing to add is life for Puritan women. 'cause it is especially hard, it's defined by total submission to men where they are, Adam, essentially on the same level as children, no rights not allowed to vote.

They're treated as property. It's, it's awful for them.

[00:34:50] Adam Cox: So what they, what? They have children, but yet they're treated the same.

[00:34:53] Kyle Risi: Yeah. That is it. Yeah. And on top of that, they were also expected to manage the home, raise the children, carry out a huge amount of physical labour, all while remaining obedient, modest.

So they're also expected to. Adopt a model of silence as well. So you've got all these like young kids and women who love nothing more than a bit of gossip. Do you know what I mean? I'm as a gay man, it's the thing I love the most. And to like, no, you're not allowed to gossip. You're not allowed to even speak.

You can imagine how like inside there's like you just

[00:35:25] Adam Cox: turmoil.

[00:35:26] Kyle Risi: Yeah. You just wanna sing Mama Mia. Do you know what I mean? So anything like speaking outta turn, gossiping or arguing with your husband was seen as a sin against God and a disruption to public order. It's incredibly oppressive to women. And what is wild is that many of these restrictions that are placed on these women are supposedly put their own protection because imp Puritan theology, they're taught the eve archetype.

Mm-hmm. Which is that women by nature are way more vulnerable to temptation and therefore were more susceptible to influence from the devil. I

[00:35:56] Adam Cox: wonder who came up with that? Was it a man?

[00:35:59] Kyle Risi: Oh yeah, 100%. All the men. And so when these accusations finally began, the community had already been taught to believe that they kind of, it was all the devil's work anyway.

Right?

[00:36:11] Adam Cox: We can't trust them.

[00:36:12] Kyle Risi: No. Yeah, exactly. It's like, well, she's a woman. The next thing to add is that Salem Village is also relatively new settlement, which means that arguments over land and property are literally everywhere. They're constantly fighting over property boundaries and grazing rights for their cattle.

And so if you mix that in with obsessively looking for signs for who is going to heaven, you can understand how this can lead to a very judgmental and resentful environment.

[00:36:36] Adam Cox: Yeah. I don't wanna go here.

[00:36:38] Kyle Risi: No, this

[00:36:38] Adam Cox: is not a good place.

[00:36:39] Kyle Risi: I don't wanna go anywhere near colonial colonies. American colonial colonies

[00:36:44] Adam Cox: not good for a long weekend.

[00:36:45] Kyle Risi: No, no. But there's one more thing to add to the frustration in this little village, and that is that whenever they wanted to settle dispute, or even go to church, which is like literally every week, sometimes multiple times a week, they were expected to travel at six miles to Salem Town. So on top of all the work, the fear, the oppression, they were constantly travelling back and forth.

And so for years, Salem campaign for more independence, including the right to build their own meeting house and appoint their own church ministers, because that will just solve everything, right? Mm-hmm. If you are not having to walk six miles, like multiple times a week, think about how much extra gossiping you could do behind people's backs.

[00:37:25] Adam Cox: That's a lot more gossiping.

[00:37:26] Kyle Risi: Yeah. And maybe you can milk a couple extra cows.

[00:37:28] Adam Cox: Sure.

[00:37:29] Kyle Risi: Now, eventually, Salem Town authorities do give in, and they do allow the village to appoint their own minister. However, Adam, the chaos and the lack of authority in this village meant that nobody could agree who the ministers should be, or how much they should be paid, like is a nightmare.

It goes like months and months and months, and they still don't have a minister. So

[00:37:48] Adam Cox: there's no like election. It's just a few people that are trying to decide this.

[00:37:51] Kyle Risi: Yeah. There, it's basically a job interview, but everyone has a say.

[00:37:55] Adam Cox: Right?

[00:37:55] Kyle Risi: But here's a problem. When they do appoint a minister, he cannot hack the infighting.

He's like, none of this is worth it. And so he just ends up resigning. What a quiet life. Yeah. And so they go through three different ministers in a very short span of time. And so eventually the job is offered to the new guy in town. It's very important to our story. And his name is Samuel Paris.

[00:38:15] Adam Cox: Mm-hmm.

[00:38:15] Kyle Risi: Who had previously served as a minister in Barbados.

[00:38:17] Adam Cox: Oh wow.

[00:38:18] Kyle Risi: Now Sam,

[00:38:19] Adam Cox: it seems like a step down though.

[00:38:20] Kyle Risi: Yeah, yeah. No sun. It is really cold and all these people are bitching.

[00:38:25] Adam Cox: He was chased out town.

[00:38:26] Kyle Risi: Yeah. Gotta be. It's the only reason why you leave Barbados. Samuel does want the job though, but he also plays very hard to get, because he knows like how many other ministers they've gone through.

And so he uses this to negotiate a better salary. He knows they're desperate. Eventually he does accept. And unlike the other ministers, though, Samuel lives for the constant feuding amongst all the villages.

[00:38:49] Adam Cox: Uhhuh,

[00:38:49] Kyle Risi: he is like intent on just making shit worse for everyone. He's a pot starer.

[00:38:53] Adam Cox: This sounds like you.

[00:38:54] Kyle Risi: He does sound like me. He's me. Oh my God. He would also use his position. I know what you're gonna say after this. He goes, this also sounds like you, he would also use his position as a minister to deliver really passive aggressive sermons, clearly aimed at particular members of the congregation.

[00:39:11] Adam Cox: Oh my God.

It does sound like you.

[00:39:15] Kyle Risi: And of course the target was veiled, but everyone knows who he was talking about. And so when Samuel comes to town, he doesn't come alone. He brings his wife. He's 9-year-old daughter Betty, and he's 11-year-old niece called Abigail Williams, but he also brings with him to enslave people.

[00:39:32] Adam Cox: Oh,

[00:39:33] Kyle Risi: SBA and John India.

[00:39:35] Adam Cox: Oh, she was a slave.

[00:39:37] Kyle Risi: She was a slave, yeah.

[00:39:39] Adam Cox: Ah, I didn't realise that.

[00:39:40] Kyle Risi: Now they may have been married. The record isn't really clear. It's also not clear whether or not SBA was Native American or Barbadian. She might have even been from Guyana. The important thing is that she is not white and she's not a Puritan.

[00:39:54] Adam Cox: When you say important, important to the story.

[00:39:56] Kyle Risi: Important to the story. Yes. Wow. Yes. So straight away she's marked out as an an outsider.

[00:40:04] Adam Cox: I see. Yeah. Clear contrast to everyone else.

[00:40:06] Kyle Risi: Exactly. And then, like I said, TBA is very, very central to the story. So not long after Samuel arrives in February of 60 92, his daughter Betty and his niece Abigail, they begin acting up and they start suffering from strange bit.

[00:40:24] Adam Cox: Okay,

[00:40:24] Kyle Risi: sound familiar?

[00:40:25] Adam Cox: Have, has the, has he diagnosed this from the playbook?

[00:40:28] Kyle Risi: Has he, well, have the kids read this playbook, essentially? Oh yeah. So they're also described as suddenly screaming for no reason. They would also throw things across the room. They would sometimes crawl under furniture, contorting themselves into weird positions.

Honestly, Adam, again, it's almost as if they're just nine and 11 years old.

[00:40:48] Adam Cox: Did kids up until this point just never, never act up,

[00:40:52] Kyle Risi: Adam. They're purs. Yeah. They, they, they live by this kind of total silence, as expected from kids and, and, and women. So yeah, this is unusual. This is unprecedented.

[00:41:02] Adam Cox: Weird.

[00:41:03] Kyle Risi: But the thing that's most concerning is they also start complaining that someone keeps pricking them with pins.

Right? Some kind of unseen force, which sounds like, if I'm honest,

[00:41:11] Adam Cox: the mother,

[00:41:12] Kyle Risi: no pins and needles from contorting themselves under furniture.

[00:41:15] Adam Cox: Oh, yeah. Probably stupid.

[00:41:17] Kyle Risi: Now this behaviour eventually spills out into church where they'll just randomly start yelling in the middle of a sermon. And collectively the village is like something, something's definitely wrong.

And so they bring in a guy called Dr. William Griggs to examine them. He can't find anything physically wrong with them. And so the natural conclusion is that the girls were under the evil hand. In other words, demons. Suddenly the girls are like, Hmm, we can work with this. And because there's no accountability for their own behaviour, two other girls in the community, they see this and they start doing exactly the same thing.

[00:41:52] Adam Cox: Our kids that conniving to go like, oh, I'm gonna play into this whole devil thing

[00:41:56] Kyle Risi: 100%.

[00:41:56] Adam Cox: Really

[00:41:57] Kyle Risi: in this story, they are. Yeah, for sure. And so now you have four girls. You've got Betty and Abigail, but now also 12-year-old Anne Putnam and Elizabeth Hubbard just being completely outta control, totally attention staffed.

Eventually Samuel's neighbour, a woman called Mary Sibley, she thinks that she can help. Her grandmother had handed down a piece of old folk magic that could potentially help work out who was possessing the girls. Now Mary instructs TBA to make something called a witch cake. The recipe is to mix ri flour with the afflicted girl's urine.

[00:42:34] Adam Cox: Ew.

[00:42:36] Kyle Risi: No. Once you mix it all together and you bake it, you're supposed to then feed it to a dog. Now the what? We need to pause there. Yes. Yes.

[00:42:46] Adam Cox: But how so? How what? You get all of their urine and then what? Four cakes and you feed it the dog and find out which one's the possessed one.

[00:42:53] Kyle Risi: No, you just make one cake.

And basically what's supposed to happen is the dog is supposed to, once you feed it to him, identify or reveal who the witch is.

[00:43:01] Adam Cox: Throw up. Yeah.

[00:43:05] Kyle Risi: It's not clear on how he does it. The only thing I can think of is that the dog would maybe do a poo spelling out the witch's name or throwing up. I'm just not sure.

Ironically, in the story, the witch cake is literally the closest anybody comes to doing anything, even remotely witchy. And so why Mary Sibley is not persecuted is completely beyond me.

[00:43:24] Adam Cox: But TPA gets the blame.

[00:43:25] Kyle Risi: Yes. She's the one who bakes the cake.

[00:43:28] Adam Cox: Oh, just because she's being, you know, ordered.

[00:43:31] Kyle Risi: Yeah. Now it's not to say that SMA doesn't kind of also get involved in some kind of weird magic things, but she brings it with her a lot of kind of her own folky stuff as well.

One of the things that the kids love to do, because remember they're bored, is they would like crack an egg into water and they would kind of watch the yoke kind of float up and to see if it kind of like maybe revealed something about who they were gonna marry. And so they liked to do that. It was one of their favourite things to do.

[00:43:54] Adam Cox: I'm gonna marry an orange man.

[00:43:57] Kyle Risi: What? Trump?

[00:43:58] Adam Cox: That's

[00:43:58] Kyle Risi: the only orange man I know.

[00:44:00] Adam Cox: Which is 'cause it was yolk.

[00:44:01] Kyle Risi: Oh, I see. I think one day they like see like a coffin up here. In fact, people say that this is the reason why the fits and the strange behaviour started, is that after they cracked this yolk, one of the girls saw a coffin and then they freaked out.

And then that's when the strange behaviour started.

[00:44:16] Adam Cox: I think it was just salmonella poisoning.

[00:44:18] Kyle Risi: I dunno if they ate the egg afterwards, Amber. But the important thing is it won't surprise you to know that the dog doesn't shit out her name.

[00:44:25] Adam Cox: Oh, really?

[00:44:25] Kyle Risi: And doesn't expose any witches identity.

[00:44:27] Adam Cox: I am shocked at that.

[00:44:30] Kyle Risi: After this, the girl's behaviour only gets worse. But when Samuel discovers that TBA had baked a cake inside his house, he's furious as far as he was concerned. A, she hadn't exposed a witch. But also now she had opened the devil's door right under his roof. And he's a minister, remember?

[00:44:46] Adam Cox: And if she's used the same cake tin with their urine in, I don't want cake, all that.

[00:44:52] Kyle Risi: No, she probably washed it.

[00:44:55] Adam Cox: Yeah. But this is no, no antibacterial stuff back then.

[00:44:59] Kyle Risi: That's true. But here's the thing though, like Mary Sibley, again, going back to her, she was the one who actually suggested the ritual. But yet she's just quietly ignoring the fact that she was evenly involved whatsoever. And so with the suspicion now on tba, along with the mounting pressure on the girls to name somebody, they end up pointing to a person least able to defend themselves.

And whose accusation was the least likely to attract? Any objection? They say it was TBA who was tormenting them.

[00:45:28] Adam Cox: Really?

[00:45:28] Kyle Risi: Yeah. Someone that they probably have a very good relationship with and probably like tells. Exactly.

[00:45:34] Adam Cox: Yeah.

[00:45:35] Kyle Risi: What a betrayal.

[00:45:36] Adam Cox: Just the kids in these stories like

[00:45:39] Kyle Risi: they're awful.

[00:45:39] Adam Cox: Horrible,

[00:45:40] Kyle Risi: awful.

They're so awful. But Adam, she's not the only person they accused. 'cause they also accused two others. A local beggar woman called Surrogate who has a reputation for being very mean. And also Sarah Osborne, a literal bedridden woman who had married her servant and recently become embroiled in a property dispute.

And so you can see what all three of these women have in common, right? They're all marginalised.

[00:46:03] Adam Cox: Mm-hmm.

[00:46:03] Kyle Risi: But also, none of them attend a church like Sarah Osborne, because of course she's literally bedridden.

[00:46:10] Adam Cox: Mm-hmm.

[00:46:10] Kyle Risi: Of course, the community are like, well being bedridden wouldn't really stop a puritan. We think that's exactly what a witch would say.

[00:46:17] Adam Cox: God

[00:46:18] Kyle Risi: so stupid and so TBA and the two Sarahs, they're arrested, they're held in prison. While the village magistrates John Hawthorne and Jonathan Corwin begin reviewing the evidence, they unanimously agree that's something which he has definitely happened. After all, they had evidence. And the evidence was something that they called spectral evidence.

[00:46:38] Adam Cox: What does that mean?

[00:46:39] Kyle Risi: It's essentially testimony from the accuser that the accused ghost or spirit had attacked them.

[00:46:44] Adam Cox: I don't feel like that's evidence.

[00:46:46] Kyle Risi: No. And so even if the accused had a solid alibi like Samuel saw TBA in the kitchen, for example, at the time of the attack, that didn't matter because as witches and the Sarahs were able to leave their physical body and torment the girls.

And so for example, I could say a cookie has gone missing from the cookie jar. And I think it was Adam. And the police would be like, well, was Adam physically present at the scene at the time of the cookie theft? And I'd be like, yes, officer, he was. And the police officer would be like, well actually under spectral evidence, that actually discounts Adam

[00:47:17] Adam Cox: because my ghost was elsewhere.

[00:47:19] Kyle Risi: Yeah, because you were physically there, so like it couldn't have been you basically.

[00:47:22] Adam Cox: Oh, okay.

[00:47:22] Kyle Risi: So they're like, Adam, you're free to go. And you'll be like, good, I'm taking this cookie compensation.

[00:47:27] Adam Cox: This doesn't make sense.

[00:47:28] Kyle Risi: It doesn't make any sense whatsoever. But also witches are supposed to be able to shapeshift as well and take any form of any animal that they want.

And so even if you like see a robin on the window sill, an accuser could say, well that was sits of a spectral form basically. Or like a shapeshift form

[00:47:42] Adam Cox: thing is if these people were witches, they would not be hanging around with these people.

[00:47:46] Kyle Risi: Exactly. So logical. And so with special evidence as a basis for these accusations, the magistrates are like, the evidence is damning.

[00:47:57] Adam Cox: These people are thick as shit.

[00:47:59] Kyle Risi: And so over the course of several days, TBA and the two Sarahs are questioned in front of the whole village, Adam at a sort of like pretrial. It's not official just yet. Sarah Goode and Sarah Osborn, they deny everything, but every time either one of them spoke, the girls who had accused them would suddenly just scream and collapse on the floor and begin convulsing.

They're like, help. She's got me.

[00:48:21] Adam Cox: Do you think like it was their parents saying like, you need to play into this.

[00:48:25] Kyle Risi: Possibly it could be, because remember, they also had disputes to settle here, right?

[00:48:29] Adam Cox: Yeah.

[00:48:29] Kyle Risi: And so seeing this happening in this village hall, like again, people are like, well, this is damning.

However, Adam, when TBA gets up onto the stance, be questioned, she doesn't deny any of it. In fact, Adam, she confesses, she tells the court or the village hall that the devil had come to her and bid her to serve him. She then spins this elaborate story involving the devil, strange animal, supernatural flights, secret meetings in the night and says, yes, I have been tormenting those girls.

And the girls are like, what game is she playing? We know why we are lying, but why is she lying?

[00:49:12] Adam Cox: Yeah, like double bluffing. Why would TBA say this? Because it does. She just want, does she want out? Has she had enough sort thing?

[00:49:19] Kyle Risi: Well, we're gonna get into that in just a second, but when she says this, the magistrates or the ministers, because they're not magistrates just yet, they go, thank you, Tituba.

Finally. And they look over at the S, someone is telling the truth. And so. TBA then tells magistrates that at one point she was invited to sign her name in the devil's book. This is a contract that you sign, right? Which is a big heretical crime. When the magistrates ask, who else signed the book? TBA slowly raises a hand.

She scans a room and points to two other people in the room.

[00:49:56] Adam Cox: This the two girls, Sarah and what's her face?

[00:49:58] Kyle Risi: Sarah Good. And Sarah Osborne. So one interpretation as to why she does this. She's basically fingering them and going like there are witches as well. And so one interpretation why she does this is that Sper might actually be trying to save their lives.

Now, I know it does make sense, even though TBA isn't Puritan herself, she understands their beliefs. Remember, she is the enslaved person of the town minister. And so she knows that a confession may be interpreted as a sign of repentance, and so she might be spared from execution, right?

[00:50:30] Adam Cox: Oh, okay. So that's why.

[00:50:32] Kyle Risi: Yeah. So it is a gamble. And by naming Sarah Good and Sarah Osborne, she's likely hoping they'll feel like they no longer have a choice but to confess as well.

[00:50:41] Adam Cox: Or is she just making herself look good going like, Hey, I, I admitted it. They didn't kill them.

[00:50:47] Kyle Risi: Possibly. I doubt it though. I think she's genuinely trying to save them.

That's my interpretation. We don't know though. But here's the thing, neither Sarah's confess,

[00:50:55] Adam Cox: well, you don't want to, it's heart to come back from that.

[00:50:57] Kyle Risi: Exactly. And the reason why they don't is while they might be spared, they don't wanna spend the rest of their lives as outcasts.

[00:51:04] Adam Cox: Hmm.

[00:51:04] Kyle Risi: Also, as Puritan confessing to something like this would essentially be lying.

Right? So it goes against their Puritan values. They didn't wanna do that. And so the two Sarahs will now have to stand trial. As for tpa, her strategy worked. Right? But a confession doesn't raise a crime. If anything, it only proves Adam, and this is the key thing, that witchcraft was real. And so she has to stay in prison.

But still, it's better than being hung. Right?

[00:51:29] Adam Cox: I guess. But I can't imagine prison's gonna be that nice either.

[00:51:32] Kyle Risi: No, it's not. That's yes. Exactly. So she's smart. And this is the, actually the playbook that others will eventually adopt. As for Sarah Osborne, Adam, she obviously has to stay in prison until her trial starts.

Remember? She's bedridden.

[00:51:47] Adam Cox: Mm.

[00:51:47] Kyle Risi: And so she's too weak and she ends up dying while she awaits trial.

[00:51:51] Adam Cox: Really?

[00:51:52] Kyle Risi: So technically she's the first kind of casualty of this, which is awful. But here's the most important thing that really kicks all of this off, because all of this could have ended right here, right now.

But while being questioned, the ministers of the church asked TBA if there were any other names besides the two Sarahs written in the devil's book. And TBA could have in this moment said no. Instead she says yes, but she couldn't read their names. And so in a town that's already deeply paranoid. The villagers are convinced that there are more witches hiding amongst them.

[00:52:25] Adam Cox: So why did TBA do this? What's take the heat off her? Is she just having fun? Like, well, I'm gonna be in prison. Let's, let's make

[00:52:33] Kyle Risi: it's, it's a question that I don't have the answer

[00:52:35] Adam Cox: to. I guess no one knows this, right?

[00:52:37] Kyle Risi: No. Like, why would she say maybe she did it accidentally? I don't know. Very interesting. But it's this thing that sparks the rest of the community

[00:52:45] Adam Cox: into this panic, I guess.

[00:52:46] Kyle Risi: Yeah. And so suddenly all over town people are whispering about who these other witches could be. They're like, honestly, I love her. Like, like she's kind of a problem. I feel super bad, but I'm also like, I think she might be a witch. You know what I mean?

[00:52:59] Adam Cox: So tits. But she the first admitting witch then there ever was,

[00:53:04] Kyle Risi: not ever was.

No, no. Salem didn't invent witchcraft.

[00:53:09] Adam Cox: No, no, no. But in, in Salem, she was the first one to admit. Yeah,

[00:53:12] Kyle Risi: she confess. Yeah.

[00:53:13] Adam Cox: So, and then that's just kind of escalate, right?

[00:53:17] Kyle Risi: Yeah. That's it. And so throughout March, more townspeople are accused of witchcraft. It's not just the girls anymore that are throwing around accusations, however, it's still them mostly, but it's now pretty much everyone.

The next three to be accused are Martha Corey, Rebecca, nurse and Dorothy Goode. It's the same story. Their spectral forms had attacked people in the night, and at the heart of most of the accusations is some kind of quarrel or dispute or question over that person's morality. Like you can almost trace that to every single person that's accused.

Remember, they're all looking for signs. The theory behind why Martha Corey was accused is that she began opening, questioning the allegations of the, of the three women. Like guys, now just hear me out. What if the girls are just making all of this up and the villagers are like, which

[00:54:07] Adam Cox: she's using common sense rationality.

[00:54:09] Kyle Risi: You're making us think it's less clear why Rebecca NUS was accused. It may come down to jealousy and resentment or some kind of old grudge connected to her status in the community. Because Adam, unlike the earlier accused, Martha and Rebecca, they're really well respected members of the community. Their opinions carried weight, and they were exactly the kind of people who could make others question what was happening.

[00:54:33] Adam Cox: Mm-hmm.

[00:54:33] Kyle Risi: And so it is very possible that they were targeted just purely to silence them.

[00:54:38] Adam Cox: Yeah.

[00:54:38] Kyle Risi: But once respected people started being accused, the dynamic completely flips. Suddenly anyone in the community could be a witch. Some did try and start a petition to defend Rebecca's character. Not Martha though.

Like she can suck it. But even signing that petition was risky because in effect, you were getting in the way of other people potentially settling scores.

[00:54:59] Adam Cox: Mm-hmm.

[00:54:59] Kyle Risi: So you might piss someone off and then you could easily be accused next because like, Hey, you foiled my attempt at trying to accuse that person.

[00:55:06] Adam Cox: I see.

[00:55:07] Kyle Risi: Now the third person to be accused in this late dispatch was someone called Dorothy. Good. She's actually Sarah Goode's daughter. And Adam, she's four years old.

[00:55:17] Adam Cox: What? Yeah. She doesn't know She's a witch.

[00:55:19] Kyle Risi: Yeah. She's so small that authorities have to make custom shackles for her and then they interrogate her in front of the entire town all while her snotty nose accuser sit there and watch.

They see absolutely no problem with what is happening in this moment. Dorothy being four, of course she's completely incoherence, but everything she says is interpreted as evidence for Witchery. And remember, all she probably wants is to be with her mom. So she'd probably saying whatever she thinks she needs to like to be with her mom.

Unaware of the consequences.

[00:55:55] Adam Cox: Yeah.

[00:55:55] Kyle Risi: Also, what I don't understand is the logic in keeping them in prison. It makes me question whether or not they truly believed that there were actual witches out there. They're supposed to have these spectral powers. They could easily just let themselves out. Right. But everyone seems to just ignore that fact.

And it's because I think that they know this is all bullshit.

[00:56:12] Adam Cox: Well, they did want to go against the grain. 'cause I guess if someone actually says, hang on a minute, I don't think this is true.

[00:56:18] Kyle Risi: Well, yeah, exactly. Same with the petition, right? You sign that petition, that's you going against the grain. You voice your concern, you'll get accused.

So

[00:56:25] Adam Cox: yes, you just go with everyone else.

[00:56:26] Kyle Risi: And so throughout April, even more people are accused. This includes Martha, Corey's husband, Giles, Corey like you, your wife made us think. And so he's accused

[00:56:36] Adam Cox: like, how many people do they think is now a witch?

[00:56:39] Kyle Risi: Oh, Adam, we'll get into it. It is a lot. They also accuse a girl called Abigail Hobbes, deliverance Hobbes.

I think there might be related. Mary Warren and a woman called, uh, Bridget Bishop. Immediately, Abigail Hobbs marry and deliverance. They confess it was well established now that they were following TPEs strategy to help them avoid execution. Right. Like they, they knew this could potentially work, but with every confession, the accused are forced into identifying names that they'd also seen written in the devil's book.

And so by the end of April 21, people have been accused and arrested.

[00:57:15] Adam Cox: That's what I mean. Like they're still expecting people to be accused. Like the whole, they carried this on the whole village would've been.

[00:57:21] Kyle Risi: Exactly. Yeah. Just to illustrate how absurd this is all becoming one of the people that they accused as a guy called George Burrows.

Now George was one of the former ministers who resigned because of all the town quarrelling, right? Mm-hmm. He had since left Salem and had moved to Maine, but because the attacks supposedly spectral in nature, distance doesn't matter. And so George is arrested. He's brought back to Massachusetts for questioning

[00:57:44] Adam Cox: and he probably is like, what's been going on?

[00:57:46] Kyle Risi: Yeah.

[00:57:46] Adam Cox: I haven't got a clue.

[00:57:47] Kyle Risi: Exactly. Throughout May, the number of the accused reaches 62 people. Again, many of them confess, but a law refused because again, it goes against the Puritan values. Right.

[00:57:58] Adam Cox: So all these people that have confessed or been accused, are they all being like their prison must be getting big, right?

Or are they being executed at this point?

[00:58:06] Kyle Risi: No one is been executed right now, but they will start to, because the number is swelling, right? They're running outta space.

[00:58:12] Adam Cox: Mm-hmm.

[00:58:13] Kyle Risi: With these numbers, swelling, pressure amounts to begin these trials. Remember all of this kicks off in March. Some people have been literally sitting in prison for three months.

The delay in starting the trials was because they needed permission to establish a court. Remember, they're under the control of Salem Town, and so they have to wait for an official chief magistrate to be appointed. This finally happens though, in June of 60 92, the job was given to a guy called Lieutenant Governor William Stren, who then goes ahead and appoints nine judges and 12 jurors to assist him.

And so finally, the trials can begin. The first BE trial is someone I mentioned earlier on Bridget Bishop. She was part of kind of the, the third batch of people. Now, the claim was that Bridget Spectre had attacked several people in the night, including Anne Putnam Jr. She was a girl who first jumps on the bandwagon after Samuel's daughter, and he started saying someone was tormenting them.

[00:59:05] Adam Cox: Mm-hmm.

[00:59:06] Kyle Risi: And was like, Ooh, I like this. And so she becomes one of the most prolific accusers in the town. While everyone else is just settling debts. Anne Putman literally just wants to watch the world burn. Like she's that kind of girl.

[00:59:18] Adam Cox: She has vindictive.

[00:59:19] Kyle Risi: She is so vindictive. She says that Bridget Spectre had sat on her chest and choked her in the middle of the night like a sleep demon.

[00:59:25] Adam Cox: Bridget does not want do that.

[00:59:27] Kyle Risi: Yeah, gross. When was the last time you showered Dan? Her testimony is backed up by other similar accounts, largely from the villagers who didn't like British's moral kind of conduct around the village. For one, she ran a tavern, and also she didn't really shy away from arguing with people in public, especially men.

One accuses happens to be a local man who she had come to blows with in the cabin. He says that Bridget Spectre had laid down on top of him one night, and basically he was unable to move. So basically she was also a spectral whore.

[00:59:59] Adam Cox: Wishful thinking.

[01:00:00] Kyle Risi: Yeah, exactly. Is that the only way you think you can get it?

During her trial, one of the things that they really latch onto is that her clothes were too colourful for a Puritan woman. What? I know, it's so dumb. They also become fixated on an awkwardly torn section of her coat, which they, they say is a very clear sign of an affiliation with the devil

[01:00:23] Adam Cox: tear in her coat.

[01:00:25] Kyle Risi: Yeah.

[01:00:25] Adam Cox: Whereabouts is that tear?

[01:00:27] Kyle Risi: Um, it was on her coat. It was just awkwardly torn. I don't know.

[01:00:30] Adam Cox: This is stupid.

[01:00:31] Kyle Risi: Uh, very stupid. At the end of a trial, Adam Bridget is found guilty and on the 10th of June 60 92, she becomes the very first person to be executed in the Salem Witch trials. And Anne Patnam is like, yay.

Again. Again, like she's awful. And get this, Bridget Bishop was from Norwich, was

[01:00:50] Adam Cox: she?

[01:00:50] Kyle Risi: Yeah. Now we can't be sure exactly, but she did marry her husband, St. Mary in the Marsh Church in 1660. Only a partial section of the wall exists today, but you can go and see it inside the cathedral. Close. It's like a church.

It was a church that was inside there. Right. And it now forms like one of the terrace houses. But this is, but yeah, this is a link to Norwich, which I think is really cool. This was our second link. The first one had to do with the blood liable, but I had to take that out because of the, the whole history of witchcraft in Europe.

[01:01:18] Adam Cox: So the first witch, or, you know, accused witch was from Norwich.

[01:01:23] Kyle Risi: Mm.

[01:01:23] Adam Cox: Wow. Yes. So where did she go over that? Like for a better life? She believed in the whole sort of, she was a puritan, I guess.

[01:01:28] Kyle Risi: I don't think she was a Puritan woman, but I mean, she was part of that group of people that kind of

[01:01:34] Adam Cox: movement

[01:01:34] Kyle Risi: went over.

Yeah. Yeah.

[01:01:36] Adam Cox: Oh,

[01:01:36] Kyle Risi: I mean, Norwich is quite an interesting kind of history with witches. Again, something else that I took out, um, during the history stuff, but we had, um, our own trials.

[01:01:46] Adam Cox: Mm-hmm.

[01:01:46] Kyle Risi: We also had our own witch tests as well. One of the most popular tests that you could do, there's a couple. First of all, you would, um, and I might do this to you later, you strip someone naked.

You shave off all their body hair, doing the eyebrows, the eyelashes, everything, pubic hair, everything. And then you scan their body for any kind of mark of the devil. Remember everyone has birthmarks or marks or whatever.

[01:02:12] Adam Cox: The third Yeah, the third nipple.

[01:02:13] Kyle Risi: Exactly.

[01:02:14] Adam Cox: Can you imagine?

[01:02:15] Kyle Risi: Yeah. Well, in the case of Bridget, they found a skin tag very explicitly.

They said it was very close to her vagina

[01:02:22] Adam Cox: and therefore very devilish.

[01:02:24] Kyle Risi: Yes. Now, in the early kind of, uh, witch hunting guides, you were supposed to then take a pin and you were supposed to prick the mark. Oh. So if you, it wasn't like a literal six, six, six birthmark on you, it might just be like a mole or something, you'd prick it, and if it didn't bleed, then you were a witch.

And the reason for that is because, uh, the devil isn't that great at making a convincing kind of version of a human being. And so he doesn't get the finer details. Right. But Adam, because at the time these witch hunts across Europe were, they were quotas. And also you were paid by the witch that was open to mass manipulation.

So people would use like re tractable pins. They would sometimes blunt the needle or switch them out because they didn't want it to bleed.

[01:03:04] Adam Cox: Oh, that's weird.

[01:03:05] Kyle Risi: It very weird.

[01:03:06] Adam Cox: I remember, I dunno if this was a tour or maybe you told me. I dunno. But there is a bridge in orange, which I think has got like a little, um, bit that you can kind of

[01:03:16] Kyle Risi: like a notch,

[01:03:17] Adam Cox: A notch out.

You can look over that. You can look over. Am I right in saying that is where they used to lower witches or cues, which is in a chair or something?

[01:03:24] Kyle Risi: Yeah. So it was called, it's called Fay Bridge. It's the very bottom of tomb land. Um, and before the witch hunts took place, this is where the town of Norwich would dunk what they called local trumpets.

[01:03:38] Adam Cox: Trumpets.

[01:03:39] Kyle Risi: And a trot was a woman who talked too much or gossiped too much.

[01:03:42] Adam Cox: It kind of sounds like something you could eat.

[01:03:44] Kyle Risi: Yeah. Yeah. It is trumpet trumpets. And yeah, they would like dunk them in the water. But obviously during the witch trials, they would also do this Here. It was one of these official tests, not officially in kind of the, the official witch hunt test, but something that evolved later on, you would typically tie your left thumb to your right toe.

You would then strap 'em into a chair. You would dunk them in. The idea is that water is pure and witches are not. And if you dunked a witch into the water, the water would reject them and they would then float. And so if they ended up sinking, you were innocent.

[01:04:15] Adam Cox: But dead.

[01:04:16] Kyle Risi: But dead. And if you floated. Then like you were a witch and then they would hang you.

[01:04:23] Adam Cox: So, so

[01:04:23] Kyle Risi: you were screwed either way.

[01:04:25] Adam Cox: Either way.

[01:04:25] Kyle Risi: Yeah.

[01:04:26] Adam Cox: That is awful, isn't it?

[01:04:27] Kyle Risi: And Norwich, at the bottom of Tomb Land is Fay Bridge, where the ribs would be far away. We would have many a drink in the evenings and that's where they would, uh, dunk trumpets and Tess for witches.

[01:04:38] Adam Cox: Yeah.

[01:04:39] Kyle Risi: And Bridget was from Norwich, which I just think is just incredible.

[01:04:42] Adam Cox: Yeah.

[01:04:43] Kyle Risi: And so Adam, the point is that Salem has now murdered its first accused witch, though there is definitely a sense of unease around this. And I think deep down inside they know that they had done wrong.

[01:04:54] Adam Cox: Well, yeah. They've just opened a Yeah. Count of worms.

[01:04:57] Kyle Risi: Yeah. And it's largely because Bridget was convicted purely on testimony of a few people who claim they'd seen her ghost.

This is enough for magistrates to adjourn the trials for 20 days while they seek advice from New England's most influential ministers. Which seems sensible. It seems like someone might be finally starting to see sense. The minister's advice, however, is that the devil can take the shape of an innocent person in order to deceive other people.

And so in theory, seeing someone spectre shouldn't be enough to prove that they are guilty, which sounds sensible. However, they say that they shouldn't stop trying. The accused just don't trust spectral evidence too much. And so Adam is completely circular. There is no objective way to decide when spectral evidence is reliable and when it is not.

However, what this does do is create a very convenient escape hatch, which only is used when someone wealthy, respected, or influential is finally accused.

[01:05:55] Adam Cox: Oh, right. So they're like, oh, okay, it, it wasn't the devil or was the devil.

[01:05:59] Kyle Risi: Well these other ones, yeah, all of the other ones. But not, not with the governor's wife.

[01:06:03] Adam Cox: Yeah. All you poor people. Yeah. You're the devil.

[01:06:07] Kyle Risi: Exactly. And so after 20 days the trials resume, they say that they'll be more cautious with reviewing spectral evidence. They aren't, because again, there's no barometer to measure that by. The next group to be trialled are Sarah Goode, Elizabeth Howell, Susanna Martin, Sarah Wise and Rebecca nurse again during court there's the usual outbursts.

Every time they would speak like,

[01:06:28] Adam Cox: ouch, she pinched my nipple

[01:06:30] Kyle Risi: like witch. It's damning, it's damning. People watching also like to play this little game where they would mirror literally everything that the accused on the stand would do and then move their hand in a particular way or shifted their position in their seats.

Other people watching would then just copy them. And the claim was that she was controlling their bodies, which is so fucking stupid because if you genuine are a witch, wouldn't you just make everyone leap to their feet and just go, she's not aware. Should we swear like you would manipulate their behaviour in that way?

Mm. Or maybe have everyone in the room collectively unshackle you help you escape, fight off the authorities in the process is all just such bullshit.

[01:07:05] Adam Cox: Yeah. Like they think these witches have got this really like incredible power, but the things that they're doing are

[01:07:10] Kyle Risi: tickling you in the night.

[01:07:11] Adam Cox: Yeah.

That's just

[01:07:15] Kyle Risi: shit tickled me.

[01:07:18] Adam Cox: It's, yeah, it just doesn't make sense.

[01:07:20] Kyle Risi: And the, the story of the guy complaining that Bridger bishop's ghost laid on top of her and he couldn't move. Like, are you complaining that you, you got sex?

[01:07:30] Adam Cox: Well that's, we don't know if that actually went down.

[01:07:33] Kyle Risi: No, no. None of it went down.

So in this latest group, all five are found guilty. And Adam, they are hung on the 19th of July, 1692. Apparently as Sarah Good was being led to the gallows. A reverend was desperately trying to persuade her to confess. 'cause he knew like, Hey, yeah, you'd still be guilty of the crime, but you wouldn't be executed.

Like hoping that she would be sped. Sarah refuses. And she says, I'm no more a witch than you are a wizard. If you take my life, God will give you blood to drink. And according to local legend years later, that Reverend died after choking on his own blood. Which throughout August the trials, they continue, six more people are found guilty and sentenced to hang, including Reverend George Barza.

Why? I'm laughing. He wasn't there basically. Remember he was in Maine.

[01:08:23] Adam Cox: Oh yeah, that's right.

[01:08:23] Kyle Risi: Yeah. And they also found guilty. Elizabeth Proctor, who had, at the time she's pregnant now. Awful. Mm. They do decide to delay her execution until after she gives birth. Now, I'd like you to kind of query, but surely if she's really witch, and I truly believe that, wouldn't that make her baby some kind of demon child

[01:08:43] Adam Cox: if she's pregnant, would she, I dunno.

Would that be passed on? And her genes the next generation.

[01:08:49] Kyle Risi: Yeah. Like a demon child?

[01:08:50] Adam Cox: Yeah.

[01:08:50] Kyle Risi: Well, the answer is no, because the puritans believe that witchcraft was a choice. Remember not a disease. It's a literal contract that you sign with the devil. And so as a foetus, you are incapable of making that choice.

[01:09:01] Adam Cox: I thought it's, you are decided whether you're gonna go to heaven or hell before you're even born. But they're saying, but you can choose to become a witch.

[01:09:08] Kyle Risi: Yeah. And surely that God would know that you'd become a witch if everything was predestined.

[01:09:13] Adam Cox: I mean, we're we're, we know this doesn't really stack up.

No. We we're questioning something as if like why did they not think

[01:09:19] Kyle Risi: of it? Yeah. That's a question. It really scholarly.

[01:09:22] Adam Cox: Yeah.

[01:09:23] Kyle Risi: You know what I mean? Have the answers, Adam. It's just human nature.

[01:09:26] Adam Cox: So she survived to give birth to her child. Yeah. And then she was hung.

[01:09:30] Kyle Risi: Yeah. That's it. So other than Elizabeth's, the other executions are scheduled for.

The 19th of August when Reverend George Burrows is led to the gallows, he begins reciting Adam the Lord's Prayer. This is big. Puran also believed that witches weren't supposed to be even capable of saying the prayer. And so in this crowd of people, everyone is like, how the fuck is he doing that? Have we got this wrong?

And so just as like people were like questioning this cotton mother, remember he was the guy who wrote the memorable providences relating to witchcraft and possessions. Mm-hmm. He steps up and he is like, guys, don't worry. I've checked. And the devil is capable of disguising himself as an angel of the lights.

And everyone is like, oh, well, oh

[01:10:16] Adam Cox: well it's good.

[01:10:17] Kyle Risi: Yeah, yeah. So hang the witch

[01:10:19] Adam Cox: that's in version two of my book, which is out now.

[01:10:21] Kyle Risi: Yeah.

[01:10:24] Adam Cox: I'm doing a signing after this execution.

[01:10:27] Kyle Risi: It'll be biscuits and some squash for the kids

[01:10:31] Adam Cox: cake.

[01:10:32] Kyle Risi: Oh my God. But Adam, under all the hysteria, the first real seas of doubts are now starting to take hold.

Of course. September, that ends up being the busiest month for all the accusations, trials and executions. In total, 15 more I found guilty and 200 people are now sitting awaiting trial in prison. Adam, it is just wild. Remember, this is a village with a population of 500.

[01:10:55] Adam Cox: Do you know what that means though?

[01:10:57] Kyle Risi: Well,

[01:10:57] Adam Cox: it means there's less people fighting over land. So this is a win.

[01:11:00] Kyle Risi: You're so good. You're so good. Yeah. That's one of the theories, right? Like the thing is though, almost everyone who is accused does confess. In fact, not a single person who confesses is executed like so thanks tba. Like she gave them the playbook.

So she kind of like, maybe she couldn't prevent this whole kind of hysteria, but she gave them like the playbook to play by.

[01:11:20] Adam Cox: Yeah. It's uh, interesting. So she's still in prison at this point then?

[01:11:24] Kyle Risi: Yes, she is. Yeah. But I also don't understand why everyone doesn't confess, right? Sure. They don't wanna live in a community as outcast, but surely if everyone's reputation is ruined, then nobody's reputation is ruined.

[01:11:37] Adam Cox: Do you know what I mean? They can start again.

[01:11:40] Kyle Risi: Yeah. By September 20, people have now been essentially hung.

[01:11:45] Adam Cox: Mm-hmm.

[01:11:45] Kyle Risi: Five more die. Because what technically, sorry. By the end of September 19, people have now been hung five more die, of course, because of the horrific conditions inside prison. And one dies because of torture.

And that was Giles Corey, he's the husband of Martha Corey. Remember the woman who had first suggested that perhaps the girls are lying and then they accused him 'cause of like your wife made us think he was originally member arrested back in April. And since then he'd refused to enter into a plea of innocence or guilty.

Now remember, without a plea, the court isn't permitted to try him. And so in September, after months awaiting, the court finally decides that if Giles isn't going to plead, we'll just force him to do it. And what they do is they bring him out in front of the village, they lay him down on the ground and place a, and they place a massive, large wooden board across his body.

Then one by one, they start placing these really heavy rocks on top of him each time saying, how do you play? And each time he just goes. More weight. So yeah,

[01:12:45] Adam Cox: it's a sucker for punishment.

[01:12:46] Kyle Risi: Yeah. Did you think you liked it?

[01:12:48] Adam Cox: Glad, glad sucker for gluttony.

[01:12:51] Kyle Risi: I think sucker for punishment is probably accurate here.

Not gni, but yeah, eventually they just keep adding more and more rocks and he is crushed to deaths. Awful. Now, the theory behind why he refused to plea was that this was also a strategy like his wife. He didn't want to lie and confess going against his Puritan values.

[01:13:09] Adam Cox: Mm.

[01:13:10] Kyle Risi: But also, he didn't want to go through a trial and likely know that he would be found guilty.

Because when that happened, what had typically happened is the government would seize all of your land and property.

[01:13:19] Adam Cox: Oh, I see.

[01:13:20] Kyle Risi: So dying without pleading meant that he was technically innocent and therefore could pass his estate onto his family without it affecting his entire bloodline.

[01:13:28] Adam Cox: So that's why some people did this then.

Yeah.

[01:13:30] Kyle Risi: Yeah. But it also explains why some people were accusing the neighbours. If someone owned a bit of property that you had your eye on, accusing them of witchcraft was a handy way of getting the government to seize that land. And then it'd be put up for auction.

[01:13:43] Adam Cox: Yeah, that'd be great if you could do that to literally all the neighbours around you, you can then like just triple your land.

[01:13:48] Kyle Risi: Yeah, for sure. And so within all this chaos, there's a tonne of opportunity for people like to accuse the other people.

[01:13:54] Adam Cox: Yeah. You can get away with it. Now start. Should we start accusing the neighbours of witchcraft?

[01:13:57] Kyle Risi: Yes.

[01:13:58] Adam Cox: Yeah.

[01:13:58] Kyle Risi: Yes.

[01:13:59] Adam Cox: Good. Let's do it.

[01:14:00] Kyle Risi: In October, everything changes. When whispers start circulating that more and more prominent people, not just in Salem Village, but across Massachusetts, were witches people like respected merchants, Boston ministers, and most prominently Lady Mary Phipps, Adam, the governor's wife, right?

Her accusation came after she literally signed a petition to release another accused prisoner. And so the locals were like, she doesn't even live here. Why the fuck is she getting involved? And immediately afterwards, someone claims that her Spectre had attacked them in the night. Of course, this is when magistrates decide things have gone too far.

Like the governor's wife cannot be a witch. She's the governor's wife.

[01:14:40] Adam Cox: But hang on, why don't they get, um, you know, cotton guy back here we are to vouch

[01:14:45] Kyle Risi: guys. I have another book coming out

[01:14:49] Adam Cox: and then it does, it does say that she could be a, yeah, she could be a witch.

[01:14:53] Kyle Risi: Uh, finally, all of this grabs the governor's attention throughout the trials, though the reason why it takes so long is because he'd been preoccupied with what was going on in the latest frontier war.

But now that his wife had been accused, he's forced to now focus his attention on what's happening in Salem. He doesn't mess around. He immediately dissolves the court. And Adam, it honestly isn't only because his wife has been accused, right? He genuinely now sees like what a literal circus this has become.

He transfers all the remaining cases to a more serious now. Like establish proper court where they at least have the sense to say law. We're not accepting spectral evidence anymore.

[01:15:33] Adam Cox: Good.

[01:15:33] Kyle Risi: And as a result, almost everyone who stands trial after this is exonerated except for three people, however, but even when the governor discovers that he revokes all of their death warrants along with death warrants for five other people who had not yet been executed.

And so Adam, the madness was finally over.

[01:15:50] Adam Cox: Thank God his wife was accused.

[01:15:52] Kyle Risi: Yeah.

[01:15:52] Adam Cox: Because yeah, he managed to actually see sense and convince people

[01:15:56] Kyle Risi: it was an inevitability that someone more prominent was going to be accused at some point

[01:16:00] Adam Cox: was And he was a puritan as well then?

[01:16:02] Kyle Risi: Yeah, I think, uh, in the kind of colonies around Massachusetts mm-hmm.

Maine and all those places, they typically all were

[01:16:09] Adam Cox: colony with scents.

[01:16:11] Kyle Risi: Yeah. Yeah. Was sense.

[01:16:13] Adam Cox: Well he, he managed to realise this is his whole shit show.

[01:16:15] Kyle Risi: But he was still a purity and he's not one of them.

[01:16:17] Adam Cox: Yeah. But he at least wasn't gonna try and kill everyone.

[01:16:20] Kyle Risi: Yeah, it's true. It's awful isn't it?

[01:16:21] Adam Cox: Yeah.

[01:16:22] Kyle Risi: Everyone's still being held in prison. He is released but not before Adam. They have to pay their jail fees like they're arrested and then they charge you for board.

[01:16:32] Adam Cox: That's crazy. That

[01:16:33] Kyle Risi: is awful. TBA is the only person who isn't released and it's because Samuel the village as a minister refused to pay her jail fees.

[01:16:42] Adam Cox: That's awful.

[01:16:43] Kyle Risi: Like it was his daughters and his niece who put TBA there in the first place. They are all such massive pieces of work is awful.

[01:16:52] Adam Cox: What about the people that she helped to like, you know, caught onto her idea? Yeah. Did they not think Oh

[01:16:57] Kyle Risi: thanks Titter Bar.

[01:16:58] Adam Cox: Yeah.

[01:16:58] Kyle Risi: None of that. TBA is eventually released, but it's not until May of 1693, so months later.

So she's the only one in jail for ages when anonymous person pays her bail and we think that maybe he might have purchased TBA from Paris.

[01:17:14] Adam Cox: Mm.

[01:17:14] Kyle Risi: But after this TBA leaves Massachusetts with him and from here Adam, she completely disappears from the historical record altogether. And we have no idea where she went.

[01:17:24] Adam Cox: Hopefully at nicer life.

[01:17:26] Kyle Risi: Almost certainly she went back into servitude. Like she probably remained a slave. But for someone so prominent in the story because of who she was as an a slave woman, there's no record of her left because that's how little she meant. Which is awful, but it's just crazy. But also imagine being set free and having to go and live back with a Paris Parises knowing every day those that are fuckers were perfectly happy to see you be executed.

[01:17:52] Adam Cox: Mm.

[01:17:53] Kyle Risi: Yeah.

[01:17:53] Adam Cox: That's harsh.

[01:17:55] Kyle Risi: And we aren't really sure whether or not John India was her partner or her husband.

[01:18:00] Adam Cox: Mm-hmm.

[01:18:01] Kyle Risi: If he was, that's devastating. Like she was taken away from him.

[01:18:03] Adam Cox: Yeah, yeah.

[01:18:04] Kyle Risi: Shame. And it's also really misogynistic and also a little bit racist in when you see the way that she's depicted in a lot of the illustrations from the time classic witch with, with brown skin.

So, and like when you look at some of the other witches that were accused, like the ones that were, were executed so there was defined they were witch, they looked perfectly fine, but sba, she looks grotesque.

[01:18:25] Adam Cox: Yeah. It's awful. It's that period of America, which yeah, I think people would rather. Well wish didn't happen, right?

[01:18:31] Kyle Risi: Yeah. And so Adam, in the aftermath, it takes Salem Village some time to reflect on the madness, but they do eventually recognise what a mess all of this had become in, and that takes a long time. The first is January 60, 97. Massachusetts holds a public day of fasting and prayer to ask God for forgiveness for this tragedy, which, you know, one day without a meal should cover it.

[01:18:53] Adam Cox: We just skip something. This Hugh's gonna take 12 hours. So yeah, we'll just call this a day of forgiveness.

[01:18:59] Kyle Risi: Shall we skip brunch? Yeah, we fine. Good. Yeah, I'm busy that day. Anyway, eventually Judge Samuel Seawall, he's one of the nine judges, he publicly accepts blame for his role in the trials, all 12 of the jurors.

They also sign a statement apologising for convicting a bunch of innocent people. 10 years after this, in 1706, Anne Putnam Jr. One of the most prolific accusers in the village. She stands up in church and she apologises for accusing everyone. She basically says that the devil had deluded her into accusing everyone.

She's the only accuser who's ever apologised, if you could even call it an apology, because essentially she, she's essentially blaming the devil who was sitting there going go. God, I did. It wasn't me. Nothing. I was, I was at my condo in Boca a year later in 1711, Massachusetts legislature, I can't even say that.

Leg legislature, legislature. Legislature.

[01:19:59] Adam Cox: I don't know what you're saying.

[01:20:01] Kyle Risi: The government of Massachusetts.

[01:20:03] Adam Cox: Mm-hmm.

[01:20:03] Kyle Risi: They basically reverse 22 of the convictions, which is a little bit late because of course so many people's lives have been ruined. But also it was only 22 because those are the only names that appeared on a petition that was submitted to the court.

It was like 200 people. Yeah. And so the vast majority of the accused were not included. They did approve, however, 578 pound and 12 shillings in compensation to be divided amongst those 22 and their family, which is roughly the equivalent of $25,000. But Google does say that that's not an accurate way to convert colonial money.

So we don't really know what the equivalent is.

[01:20:40] Adam Cox: Basically, it would've gone some way in repaying, you know, saying, sorry,

[01:20:44] Kyle Risi: we lost the lives of the family members. Adam, is there ever gonna be a price for that?

[01:20:49] Adam Cox: Uh, no. Maybe you mean like they could, I don't know. They're okay for life. They haven't gotta worry about food or anything.

[01:20:55] Kyle Risi: Yeah. Possi, possibly. Yes. Now it isn't until 1957 that Massachusetts formally addresses six victims who had been left out of the earlier legislation. But even then, Adam, the resolution only names like one person like Anne, I believe that's her name, like the other five, are just brushed aside as simply like certain another persons, which is so massively disrespectful.

[01:21:17] Adam Cox: Mm-hmm.

[01:21:18] Kyle Risi: In a case this historic Yeah. And it's big. Right.

[01:21:20] Adam Cox: Just not even bothering to name their names.

[01:21:23] Kyle Risi: Yeah. In 2001, Massachusetts finally goes back and names those people properly, including recognition for Susanna Martin, Bridget, Bishop Norris, massive, uh, Alice Parker, Margaret Scott, and Wilma Red. But Adam, even then, it's not everybody.

It's like, guys, just get all the names. Get all the names. You put this to bed. But no, there's still more because in 2022, a group of school children, little school children discovered that Elizabeth Johnson Jr. And never exonerated. And so as a class. All the students signed a petition. They got together, they wrote statements.

They came and kind of did all their like little spiel in their play. And they forced basically the state of Massachusetts to formally clear her name.

[01:22:06] Adam Cox: Hang on. How old are these children? Are we

[01:22:08] Kyle Risi: Very small. Really?

[01:22:09] Adam Cox: Yeah. They get it. They're like, hang on this, this woman was never exonerated

[01:22:13] Kyle Risi: this. Exactly.

It's probably like a teacher who like that to be a fun thing for our kids to do. And so they did it. Wow. Which I just think is really sweet.

[01:22:19] Adam Cox: Yeah.

[01:22:19] Kyle Risi: It only takes three 30 years. But they finally got there. And also if you are ever in Salem, you can visit the official memorial park dedicated to those who were executed.

I think the park opened like in 92, I think to mark their 300th anniversary of the trials. And inside there are 20 stone benches. Each one commemorating someone who is executed.

[01:22:41] Adam Cox: Mm-hmm.

[01:22:42] Kyle Risi: But at the same time, I guarantee you, none of them stood on those gallows thinking, don't worry, in 300 years I'll get a sweet ass bench for this trouble.

[01:22:50] Adam Cox: Yeah. Probably not.

[01:22:51] Kyle Risi: No, they're probably, they're like in life, not enough people sat on me. And so in death, I'm gonna make up for that.

[01:22:59] Adam Cox: Yeah. I wanna bench.

[01:23:01] Kyle Risi: Yeah, I wanna bench to commemorate myself and Adam. That is the story of the Salem. Which trials of 1692.

[01:23:09] Adam Cox: What a wild time. Which I'm glad I wasn't a part of.

[01:23:13] Kyle Risi: Mm.

[01:23:13] Adam Cox: Because I probably would've been convicted 'cause it. I dunno. I reckon I get picked on.

[01:23:17] Kyle Risi: Yeah, you do get picked on quite a lot. It's 'cause you're too nice.

[01:23:22] Adam Cox: Uh,

[01:23:23] Kyle Risi: but yeah. Isn't that crazy? So it's like very clearly a hysteria that erupted out of human nature, gossipy, kind of like debtor vendetta and grudges that needed to be settled.

[01:23:35] Adam Cox: And that's not the first time. It's not the last time is it? Oh, it's just this, I guess it's the supernatural element, which is quite strange about that period.

[01:23:42] Kyle Risi: Yeah, that's right. Yeah. It definitely fed into it because there's a lot, there's a lot of history, a lot of complication there. Mm. But also very rarely, and we've seen this with the Satanic panic, very rarely do these things like erupt from one single event where you can go, that's, that's it.

[01:23:56] Adam Cox: Mm-hmm.

[01:23:56] Kyle Risi: It's very often decades and decades in this case, centuries of conditioning and changing the way that people view the world and what they were fearful of. And that's exactly what happened here. And it's exactly what happened with other moral panics. And it's no different. And it's just crazy that for so long people refuse to accept that maybe it's our own making.

This is the result of us. 'cause they blamed like OTTs in their rye crops, which wasn't the case. It was, it's it's you guys,

[01:24:28] Adam Cox: it's just plain old being a bad human.

[01:24:31] Kyle Risi: Yeah. Yeah. And I really love the fact that we have a little connection to, um, Norwich in the story. Like such a big momentous story. So kind of iconic in history.

And now I get it, a lot of people kind of, when they think about the witch trials, they think about Sadan. But it's in nowhere near the scale of horror that happened in Europe. But this is the kind of the one single event a lot of people remember.

[01:24:55] Adam Cox: Yeah.

[01:24:55] Kyle Risi: It's crazy.

[01:24:56] Adam Cox: And so even in Salem, no one was like burnt at the stake.

[01:25:00] Kyle Risi: No. Or, or hung, yeah. Because, uh, remember there were an English colony. Mm-hmm.

[01:25:04] Adam Cox: And

[01:25:04] Kyle Risi: the crime for witchcraft was lumped in with, uh, heresy, I think throughout Europe as well. And so typically you were, you were hung. Yeah. Not, not burnt to the stake,

[01:25:15] Adam Cox: which is probably nicer the way to go.

[01:25:17] Kyle Risi: I would say so. Yeah.

Yeah. I think they, they did burn some of them. Um, but

[01:25:22] Adam Cox: not in Salem,

[01:25:23] Kyle Risi: but no, definitely not in Salem. They're all hung. Yeah. Yeah. I'm glad we've done the story finally.

[01:25:27] Adam Cox: Yeah, it's

[01:25:28] Kyle Risi: been on the list for a while.

[01:25:29] Adam Cox: Well told,

[01:25:30] Kyle Risi: and I think we should definitely do a whole history episode on history of witchcraft because it is wild.

And also what is amazing about the history is there's a lot of overlap with the shamans and the healers and all those types of people that we discussed, but also, um, heresy and the rise of the Catholic Church. But there's a lot of antisemitism in there. And one of the little anecdotes that I had in there was, um, that it can be identified that the, the real catalyst for like real extreme, brutal, systematic persecution of Jewish people across Europe can be pinpointed to one single event that happened in Norwich, literally behind our house

[01:26:12] Adam Cox: really.

[01:26:13] Kyle Risi: There's a wooded area called Thorpe Wood, where a young boy called William of Norwich was found under very suspicious circumstances. And so the Jews were blamed for his death as part of something called the Blood Libel Conspiracy. They wanted to revenge against Christians. And so they were systematically, and it's all unfounded, kidnapping Christian kids across Europe to, uh, crucify them and use their blood and rituals.

And of course, again, I'll say it completely unfounded, complete conspiracy, but it's this single moment that sparked wide, massive kind of hatred against Jews across Europe, and it all started literally on our house.

[01:26:51] Adam Cox: Wow.

[01:26:52] Kyle Risi: Anyway, Adam, do you fancy running the outro for this week?

[01:26:54] Adam Cox: Let's do it.

[01:26:55] Kyle Risi: And so that brings us to the end of another fascinating foray into the compendium and assembly of fascinating things.

We hope you enjoyed the ride as much as we did,

[01:27:03] Adam Cox: and if today's episode has sparked your curiosity, then please do us a favour and follow us on your favourite podcast app. It truly makes a world of difference and helps more people discover the show.

[01:27:13] Kyle Risi: And for our dedicated freaks out there, don't forget, the next week's episode is already waiting for you on our Patreon, and as always, it's completely free to access.

[01:27:21] Adam Cox: And if you want even more, then join our certified Freaks Tier to unlock our entire archive. You get to delve into some exclusive content and get a sneak peek at what's coming next.

[01:27:30] Kyle Risi: We drop new episodes every Tuesday and until then, remember when society loses its mind, it rarely needs the devil's help.

We'll see you next time.

[01:27:39] Adam Cox: See you.