Top True Crime Podcasts 2024 You Haven’ Yet Discovered.

Have you noticed that when you Google the top true crime podcasts 2024, or whatever the year. You just see the same old podcast shows being suggested time and time again. What we really want are those hidden true crime gems, the ones nobody knows about, but are still great!

The problem is, if you're searching for the top true crime podcasts 2024, you've probably already come across the likes of Crime Junkie and My Favorite Murder. So it’s not helpful when they appear on everyone's favourite list.

What you're really looking for is something new, noteworthy, a hidden gem to add to your podcast listening library.

Well, we've got you covered. Here are The Compendium Podcast's top true crime podcasts 2004 that you haven’t heard of! This isn't a list we plucked out of thin air. It’s a collection curated by some of the best minds in the podcast judging industry, sourced from judges of top podcast awards.

Based on their recommendations, we've tried and tested each podcast, taken them for a spin and really opened them up. Here are our top true crime podcasts of 2024 that you might not have heard of, yet!

#1 The Compendium Podcast

First up, we’ve got to talk about our very own show—because, let’s face it, we’re our biggest fans! "The Compendium Podcast" is all about exploring the darker corners of true crime, bizarre historical events, and extraordinary people. Our mission is to tell you everything you need to know about an interesting topic from the world of true crime, history or incredible people to help you get through a social gathering.

And we’re great if I don’t say so myself. With a 4.8-star rating on Spotify and Apple, it seems our listeners are just as enthusiastic about our content as we are.

June 25, 2024

65

01:16:5852.91 MB

The Giggling Granny: Nannie Doss the Serial Killer Grandma

In this episode of The Compendium, we delve into the chilling life and crimes of Nannie Doss , infamously known as "The Giggling Granny." Today’s story unravels the timeline of one of America's most notorious female serial killers, whose seemingly in...

We recommend you get started with episode 65, "The Giggling Granny: Nannie Doss the Serial Killer Grandma," which delves into the chilling life of Nannie Doss, and will definitely make you at the very least keep an eye on your own grandma.

#2 The Apartheid Killer

"The Apartheid Killer", just wow, and is a brilliant contender for our list of the top true crime podcasts 2024. This show offers a deep dive into a dark period of South African history during apartheid, exploring systemic racism and violence through the lens of Louis Van Schoor, a convicted serial killer.

This podcast stands out for its investigative depth, stemming from a four-year investigation by BBC World Service's investigative unit, BBC Africa Eye, and the World of Secrets podcast team.

What makes this podcast compelling is its exclusive access to Van Schoor, providing an unfiltered look into the mind of a killer. It also features multiple perspectives, including interviews with victims' relatives, anti-apartheid activists, and a journalist who pursued the truth for two decades.

This podcast is more than just true crime; it offers valuable insights into systemic racism and the human capacity for violence, making it essential listening for those interested in history and social justice. We love it!

#3 Ghost Story

I love Wondery and their show Ghost Story uniquely blends true crime with the supernatural, creating a compelling narrative that appeals to fans of both genres. Ghost Story is hosted by journalist Tristan Redman, the podcast explores the chilling family history involving the murder of Dr. Naomi Dancy and the subsequent suicide of her brother, Maurice, in 1937.

Redman's personal connection to the story adds emotional depth, as he delves into his own experiences of growing up in a haunted house. Spanning eight episodes, the show seamlessly shifts between true crime investigation and paranormal exploration, which just kept us super engaged the entire time with its well-paced narrative and intriguing revelations.

A particularly notable episode is the series finale, which provides a satisfying conclusion to the investigation and addresses lingering questions. This top true crime podcast 2024 is a must-listen for those who appreciate a blend of historical intrigue, family secrets, and supernatural elements.

#4 Casefile

Okay, okay, you may have heard of this one, but it’s on the list because of one particular episode which you may not have heard of but is a must. Casefile is revered for its meticulous research and respectful storytelling, narrated by an anonymous host who lets the facts take centre stage; which is completely the opposite of The Compendium which Adam likes to make all about himself in any way possible.

Each episode delves deeply into both solved and unsolved cases, offering a thorough exploration that true crime enthusiasts appreciate. "Casefile" appeals to listeners who value a serious, well-researched, and dignified approach to true crime storytelling.

#5 Blood on the Dance Floor

Just wow! Blood on the Dance Floor is a compelling podcast that investigates the unsolved murder of Darren Bradshaw, a 24-year-old off-duty police officer in Northern Ireland in 1997. This podcast offers a unique historical and cultural context, exploring gay Belfast in the late 1990s.

It’s presented by journalist Jordan Dunbar. The podcast combines thorough investigation with high-quality reporting, shedding light on often overlooked aspects of social history.

The first episode, which introduces Bradshaw's case, is particularly noteworthy, setting the stage for the series and providing crucial background information. "Blood on the Dance Floor" is perfect for those interested in true crime stories that offer insights into specific communities and historical periods.

#6 The Missing Madonna

"The Missing Madonna" explores the theft of Leonardo da Vinci's "The Madonna of the Yarnwinder" from Drumlanrig Castle. It’s a show that for us masterfully combines elements of art history and true crime, tracing the stolen painting's journey from the castle and into the deep dark criminal underworld.

Host Olivia Graham's personal connection to the story just makes it even more interesting, adding an emotional resonance to the story. The podcast features a diverse cast of characters, high production quality, and a gripping narrative.

A standout episode is "The Heist," detailing the daring theft in 2003 and capturing the tension and audacity of the crime. "The Missing Madonna" offers a rare blend of art and crime, making it a must-listen for both art enthusiasts and true crime fans.

#7 Sword and Scale

Sword and Scale is immersive and I love it. It reminds me of those old BBC radio shows my dad would listen to growing up. Using a mix of audio elements to create a vivid listening experience. The podcast presents true crime stories in their rawest form, often including 911 calls, court testimony, and interviews with victims and perpetrators.

Host Mike Boudet's unique perspective and commentary add depth to the stories, although the podcast's graphic content and unflinching approach to true crime may not be suitable for all listeners, but we just loved it!

#8 Dirty John

I love a bit of a psychological manipulation element to a story, especially when it dives into the complexities of human relationships. This show revolves around Debra Newell, a successful interior designer who falls prey to the charm of John Meehan, a sociopath whose manipulative tactics drive the narrative.

And if you thought it sounded familiar, then yes, there is a Netflix documentary of the same name and it’s just as great.

The story highlights the vulnerabilities in seemingly strong individuals, making Newell's journey relatable. With gripping storytelling, twists, and turns, "Dirty John" combines interviews, archival audio, and dramatic narrative to create a real-life thriller.

The finale is particularly notable, showcasing the shocking culmination of Newell's relationship with Meehan. This podcast invites listeners to consider the psychological and societal factors at play in cases of manipulation and abuse.

#9 Bear Brook

Bear Brook is ambitious in its storytelling. Its complex narrative structure explores a decades-long investigation involving four unidentified bodies found in barrels in New Hampshire. The show has it all: genetic genealogy, forensic techniques, detailed investigations. This show has been praised for its responsible journalism and engaging presentation, which is something that's rare in today's world.

The first episode, "Hide and Seek," sets the stage for the series, introducing the discovery of the barrels and the initial investigation. This podcast offers a unique and compelling listening experience, highlighting advancements in forensic science and the dedication of those seeking justice.

#10 In the Dark

In the Dark! Oh my God! I love this show for its exceptional investigative journalism, compelling storytelling, and ethical rigour. Everything we are not! The team, led by Madeleine Baran, dedicates extensive time and resources to uncovering the truth, often revealing systemic failures in the justice system.

The podcast focuses on the broader implications of justice and accountability, providing a profound understanding of the justice system. Each season delves into a different case, with Season 2, investigating the case of Curtis Flowers, particularly praised for its depth and impact. This season highlights the injustice and systemic racism involved in Flowers' case, offering a powerful narrative of his fight for redemption. "In the Dark" is a must-listen for those interested in true crime and justice reform.

And there you have it

So, there you have it, our top true crime podcast picks you have never heard for 2024. Whether you're into historical intrigue, psychological thrillers, or deep investigative dives, these podcasts have something for everyone. Happy listening, and stay curious!